You are saying quality of roster has little to do on how a QB performs?
Was Brees all of a sudden a mediocre QB when his team missed the playoffs the past 3 years?
Bledsoe once again was on a stacked team... They won the superbowl the year he got injured lol... 0-2 when he was playing that year. Bledsoe was an average to an above QB playing on a very good team.
It's hard to make an argument that Bledsoe is better just because he went to a superbowl. You know, Trent Dilfer won a superbowl, does that make him better than Bledsoe? And is Bledsoe also better than Philip Rivers because Rivers hasn't been to one?
Luck is a good QB who has literally carried his team to the playoffs. Without him, they are awful as we are now witnessing