Mr. WEO

So what? Rodgers is 11th--is he the 11th best QB in the league? lol, no. Is Stafford better than Josh, Goff and Mahomes?--they are all behind him in "passing". I'm wrong not infrequently, but this nonsense doesn't counter any of the points made above. With him at the helm, they have won 20 games the pas 3 years. they are 5-5 in a division that has 1 team 1 game over .500 I can be persuaded by a cogent argument....

for 2 extra 3rd rounders?? Give him a cardboard box and walk him out!

only if you don't include Jets/Giants

Neither is winning 3 of 4 SBs (in 5 seasons). Reid has never been AP COTY in KC. Playoff success may not make you a COTY, but spectacular playoff exits will keep you off it for sure. It's a bias that sticks with voters. McD isn't exactly making lemonade out lemons, despite how some posters go on...

I'm just reading the script! Stefanski and Daboll will be the COTY's fired soonest after getting the award...Nagy was gone in 3 seasons. Smith in 5. Riverboat Ron won it twice!--years was still canned 4 years later. Garret was gone after 4 years. It's a kiss of death.

Rams were 0-2 before Kupp went out. They scored a total of 30 points. Stafford+Kupp=3-3. For reference, 3 years ago, the Rams won the SB without a Nacua on the roster. Just Kupp and a funeral home waiting room of Woods, OBJ and Desean Jackson. Josh has won games without Coleman, Kincaid, Cooper. Mahomes wins without Rice. Stroud without Diggs and Collins.... Maybe he is getting the ball off quickly. He's just not getting it into the end zone. 4 of his meager 13 TDs came in his last game against an awful team.

sorry, didn't read that as cumulatively since 2020, just as highest in a year since 2020. but yes, this points to pretty stacked O/D and only 1 AFCC appearance to show for it. That' is not going to get you COTY votes. this is why he doesn't win the award.

did you watch him the week before vs. Miami? The Raiders? Packers? Cards? Bears?...........

The GB egomaniac is now in NJ. Lafleur had to put up with Rodgers's nonsense for a while. Now he they really haven't missed a beat with the QB draft pick that everyone dragged the Packers over. GB got better as soon as Rodgers left. Few assumed that would be true. McVay and Les Snead went all in for that one ring 3 years ago. They've 20 games since. And McVay traded away a guy on a rookie contract who could be MVP on a team that went from 3-13 to 30 wins since the Rams won a SB. McVay isn't that genius...

voters don't block out of their minds the playoff history of a HC when considering this year's COTY... It's not unreasonable to expect 1-14 wins a season for the Bills. Especially with everyone being back this weekend, this team is fairly stacked. see above

Lions are first in point diff, Bills #2...but it's not even close. Chargers aren't a "bad team", they just fall apart each year. Not without significant talent. Washington is pretty loaded too. Campbell should have been COTY last year (the Stefanski pick was mind numbing--he'll likely get fired after the season). So far, Campbell should be the front runner, hands down.

They can both be true. At the beginning of the season, it's hard to argue this team had significant gaps at skill positions. Plus they brought in Adams. An owner can expect that roster to win a lot of games. The problem became the O-line stinks and the QB is beyond washed up. A GM has one real job: pick the right HC/QB combo. This GM never got any of it right, so he had to go.

Does he have an amazing playoff football mind?

none of that matters. every COTY voter has seen this before: beat KC in the season, lose in playoffs. HC's in DC and Minny are working with a rookie and a former busted out rookie....not Josh Allen

he would have to at least get the team to the SB. too many view him as the reason the Bills do not advance in the playoffs----that's not going to get you the MVP.

well, the media does pick the MVP, yes...but I've been told here at TSW that the MVP goes to a #1 seed QB. anyway, Josh has received "national media" love in past seasons and mentioned as MVP. It doesn't matter.

I don't understand the fixation with "the national media" why is it important?

game of the year, you say....?

He beat a 3 win team by 6.

lol stopgap? Like who? Purdy is 6th in passing yards, 6th in QBR, has as many TDs as Herbert, more than Daniel’s/Hurts/Geno/Stroud/Murray. Tell us who you would bring in who is already better than that? McCaffrey has played 2 games, Deebo, Kittles and Aiyuk have all missed games. Their Defense is mediocre. Purdy is hardly their problem.

ask his family

My guess would be that most of those men don't struggle with being alone/keeping women away....

Stafford is on his last legs. I think the bias is still against former (good) players becoming HCs. Plus he came on as sort of a cartoon character. you can only play the teams on your schedule, they say. and Detroit is tearing opponents Defenses up. (wild stat: 6th in passing yards despite being 29th in attempts). They beat Az, Vikes, Texans, Packers. Bills beat AZ and Chiefs. They scored over 45 points in 3 of their last 6 games. Their Defense is 5th in least points allowed. They are, by far, the best team in point differential. at least he has us ahead of the Soviets would be nice!

America is last...

you're right. he won't use this windfall to pay for his obligation toward cost of building. This is for the family lifestyle fund.