Jump to content

Is now the time to panic?


mannc

Recommended Posts

my panic freakout moves

 

QB- Josh Freeman is a free agent pick him up put Tuel on the PS, cut Lewis-

 

OG- pick up Incognito and trade next years 2nd round pick for Alex Boone - starting OL Glenn, Boone,Wood, Incognito, Henderson- backup Urbik, Hairston, Richardson, Kouandijo

 

Base offense - it should be Watkins, Woods Williams, Spiller, Chandler - spread offense is where Spiller excelled with Chan

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It is becoming clearer every day that Whaley/Marrone once again made a huge (and IMO unfathomable) miscalculation by allowing this franchise to enter yet another NFL season without a viable no. 2 QB when there are very serious question marks about the anointed starter. (I maintain that the best solution would have been to use a 4th round or later pick on a QB in last April's draft, but it's too late for that now, if course.).

 

So the question is, do the Bills try to add another QB to the roster now? If so, who would you have them acquire and how much would it cost? How much would you be willing to pay?

I believe it is not too early to panic about the QB position. It appears that none of the three QB on the roster or even Dixon from the practice squad are any good at all. All have played poorly this pre-season and there is no reason to believe that any of them will be able to suddenly flip a switch once the season starts and all of a sudden play better. They need to add not one, but two QB's somehow and find someone who can at least be adequate at the position. Right now, all are epically bad.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

No, now is not the time to panic. Week 1 is still two weeks away, and even after that, this is still a year of transition....plenty of time for all the underachievers (on the field, on the sidelines, & in the front office) to prove that they deserve to stay under the new ownership. If they fail to do so & the new ownership still keeps them? That's when it's time to panic, for nothing will have changed. Until then, I'm just kicking back & watching.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's interesting how each preseason the Bills have sucked, we are told each and every time "it's just preseason, wait until the regular season". Every year. And how do the cards eventually fall? 6 win seasons. I think people are still under the impression (we saw during the SB years) that the preseason is meaningless.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Preseason is never the time to panic.

 

We all remember Levy, Kelly and company going 0-4 in preseason in 1990. In fact, I don't believe the Bills ever had a winning preseason record during the SB years. Preseason is a time for vanilla offenses, vanilla defenses and talent evaluation. Not for panic.

 

When Trent Green injured himself in a preseason game in 1999, Rams fans began to worry. Worry turned to panic when they turned the team over to a former stockboy with a 47.2 QB rating in his limited NFL action. And thus began "The Greatest Show on Turf" - which produced a victory in SB XXXIV.

 

So I wait until we start screwing up in real games before I panic.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's interesting how each preseason the Bills have sucked, we are told each and every time "it's just preseason, wait until the regular season". Every year. And how do the cards eventually fall? 6 win seasons. I think people are still under the impression (we saw during the SB years) that the preseason is meaningless.

Actually, the reason we sucked all these years is because we had inferior quarterbacking and inferior coaching and a decent roster with only one or maybe no star players on it. Sometimes we looked pretty good in preseason. Sometimes we started the season looking pretty good after a lousy preseason. There is endless evidence of good teams playing poorly in preseason and bad teams playing well in preseason.

 

We have a better team this year. We have a presently very erratic quarterback. We have suspect coaching. But I still don't think that how we play in preseason as a team has much to do how we will look when the regular season starts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I suspect that the real panic is about the starting QB.

I would consider that the heart of the matter

 

Nice perspective, always needed. I do want to say that I root for EVERY player on this team every game. My opinions never impact that. I think most of us feel the same way.

 

The issue we all have is not experiencing any on the field success for so many years makes us even more anxious to see progress, and when we don't see it (like yesterday), it's human nature to unload our opinions.

 

I know it's preseason and there is perspective to be respected, however, all of us saw what happened and from what I saw, there is reason to be very concerned about this team this year.

good post TX . I am concerned but hardly deflated
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Actually, the reason we sucked all these years is because we had inferior quarterbacking and inferior coaching and a decent roster with only one or maybe no star players on it. Sometimes we looked pretty good in preseason. Sometimes we started the season looking pretty good after a lousy preseason. There is endless evidence of good teams playing poorly in preseason and bad teams playing well in preseason.

 

We have a better team this year. We have a presently very erratic quarterback. We have suspect coaching. But I still don't think that how we play in preseason as a team has much to do how we will look when the regular season starts.

And yet players get cut or benched every year based on how they perform in the preseason, so it must mean something, especially for unproven players like the ones we are discussing here.

 

 

I suspect that the real panic is about the starting QB.

Certainly there would be far less concern about the backup position if we had a proven starter with a history of making it through the season in one piece. Edited by mannc
Link to comment
Share on other sites

And yet players get cut or benched every year based on how they perform in the preseason, so it must mean something, especially for unproven players like the ones we are discussing here.

Not really. Because coaches don't think of these games or what they see like fans do. Coaches want to see if guys can win their battles one on one, if they can execute their assignments (which we don't know what they are), if they use the techniques they were taught in practice in the games against other players, if they can communicate with their teammates in the middle of a game, etc. it's a completely different set of criterion. And they can get the answers, win or lose, play well or play bad as a team, from watching live and more so watching tape after the game.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It is becoming clearer every day that Whaley/Marrone once again made a huge (and IMO unfathomable) miscalculation by allowing this franchise to enter yet another NFL season without a viable no. 2 QB when there are very serious question marks about the anointed starter. (I maintain that the best solution would have been to use a 4th round or later pick on a QB in last April's draft, but it's too late for that now, if course.).

 

So the question is, do the Bills try to add another QB to the roster now? If so, who would you have them acquire and how much would it cost? How much would you be willing to pay?

Panic over a #2 QB? You are a lightweight. There are people here panicking over the #1 QB! :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Somewhere over on Eagles forum.... "Think we could trade Barkley for Tuel, he looked pretty good this pre-season?"

 

Somewhere over on Dolphins forum.... "Think we could pick up Thad Lewis, he looked pretty good beating us twice last year?"

 

Somewhere over on Skins forum.... "We need to trade Cousins or RG3 and get something for the draft, we have too many holes to fill".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...