JohnNord

Oh yeah they would reject it in the length alone! The thing is writing an editorial is a type of journalism, but it’s not the type of unbiased reporting you’d see three long articles with anonymous sources. That’s where I think the lines got blurred a bit. It seems that rather than positing the series as his opinion, Dunne presented it almost as an investigative report that went behind closed doors. When he went on Colin Cowherd, he didn’t say “Here’s why I think Sean is the problem.” It was “here’s why Sean McDermott is the problem” So right off the bat, fans started question his bias. Of course, it’s an editorial so he should be biased - his mind is already made up. But that…and some of the personal shots is why I don’t think Dunne got what he was looking for from this article

I added the link… As far as Dunne he’s definitely keeping a low profile on Twitter. He released two new GoLong podcasts - neither of he promoted on Twitter. It’s a far contrast from his own Substack site where he issued a scathing response to the controversy. Like the podcast mentioned, had the article simply been framed differently the response likely wouldn’t have been as negative

If you listen to the first 15 minutes of the Bruce Exclusive podcast, he does a brilliant job discussing the problem with the series. His point is that the articles were an “editorial with sources” but were not framed that way. Instead they were framed almost like an investigative piece. Bruce said that for years, Dunne has expressed the opinion that Sean McDermott is the problem in Buffalo. So he started writing the series with that opinion, and found evidence (through sources) to help lend credibility to his opinion. Dunne is “driving the car and steering where it goes.” This was my main takeaway and the biggest criticism I had when people said “well he did include positive things about McDermott too.” Bruce just did a much better job articulating what I meant to say! This was always a well-sources editorial and not a balanced news story. I feel if people took the series as his opinion, rather than proof of McDermott as a coach - the response would have been different and Dunne could stop hiding from the angry mob on Twitter and wouldn’t have to hide his thoughts behind a wall.

Especially considering Josh has proven he can sling it in the rain. It fascinating to me how Dallas is so focused on the weather. It’s like they’ve never played in 40 degree weather before. It sounds as though they are anticipating the “cold,” rain, and maybe wind will have a big enough effect on them that they need to prepare for it - when really, it’s football weather. I’m hoping this throws them off a bit

Everyone in Dallas is talking about preparing for the “cold in Buffalo.” It’s going to be 48 degrees! Hopefully it pours. We know Josh can sling it in a monsoon

Earlier this year John Murphy did some book signings around Buffalo and Rochester. He is in good health but apparently not able to return to the broadcast booth. The stroke likely affects his speech which is why he is not back. I think he was optimistic to return but given his age, I don’t see that happening. https://www.lockportjournal.com/news/bills-play-by-play-man-john-murphy-looks-back-in-lockport-with-his-new-book/article_e67aec94-6d51-11ee-be34-937db5c7dd4f.html No one knows anything about Kim Pegula. According to the players tribune article, my guess is that she’s still mostly non-verbal and struggling to get back to where she was before. It’s an extremely sad story Both are fine and will play Sunday Did you actually talk with him?

I think weather is only part of reason why Buffalo would never see a Super Bowl. Even if they put a dome on the new stadium and put the stadium downtown, Buffalo is still too small of a city to host that big of an event. The NFL did host Super Bowl 26 in Minnesota in the dead of winter. It was freezing and there was a ton of snow but cancelled flights etc didn’t have much of any effect on the decision.

No, not really. You made the assumptions about the situation that I did.

🤣 Coverage units have definitely been worse but I feel some of that is related Sam Martin’s lousy punting. The only reason I see Matt Smiley back is some amazing turnaround. This unit has struggled all season long. Really the one exceptional moment has been Reggie Gilliam’s monster hit to force a fumble at NYJ.

I think some fans are sleeping on Dallas. They are a very good team with a lot of talent at key positions. The strange thing about Dallas is that they typically don’t well on the road, sans a beat down of the worst team in the NFL. I think points are going to be scored and it will be closer. I’m hoping the Bills can find a way to pull it out

I wasn’t too impressed with Justin Shorter in preseason. He had one decent game if I can recall correctly but also was very inconsistent. As long as there are no serious injuries to the WR, I’d guess that the Bills will shut him down after the window expires

Wayne Arnold… do you really want me to go through the post and bold all of your assumptions. I really don’t want to. But I will. I can think of one off the top of my head - you said he made a “load of money.” Assumption 1 McDermott deserves criticism but at least be fair. To pretend he’s bad coach who just “lucked into Allen” is just not true.

I hope you are correct. I’ve noticed that Poyer has 0 INTs this year, whereas last year he had 5 in 12 games and 4 in the season before. Not sure what to attribute this to, but I’m hoping that number picks up soon

Individually there’s a lot of talent in the Miami defense. They had been playing previously - even holding KC to 14 points but they offered little resistance on Monday when it mattered - which was bizarre. I’m not certain some of the talent he inherited is a perfect match for the Fangio scheme.

Yes and no. He’ll be good for a few reps but there’s also a reason he was on his couch until week 13. The gap between Ingram and Phillips in 2023 is wide

Id say that’s selling both teams short. The talent on the Miami defense is good. I think Phillips being out hurts bad. But aside from the CB’s there is a solid Safety in Holland and also good players like Chubb and Wilkins and unheralded players like Van Ginkel and Sieler. The defense has played better with Jalen in the lineup

I was just about to say that. Josh threw a perfect pass into the scrum and Shakir was right there. Unfortunately KC had players right where they needed to be and the ball was knocked down. It was a good rep for both sides

I don’t know if it’s a problem. We likely have our starting 2 CB’s next for next season in Benford and Douglas Im not sure why you put Taron on this list. He’s an important part of the defense and I am certain he returns at slot CB next season. I’d also bet Hyde and Poyer are both gone, which means they need to find 2 new safeties. One idea had been moving Benford to safety but think he’s played too well. I don’t see them valuing Damar as a starter. Buffalo probably has room for one decent free agent signing. I would love to see them sign Kyle Duggar from NE to fill one of these spots but not sure what $ he will command. The biggest question make is Tre White. The Bills will want to give him every chance to comeback but reality and his contract probably say to move on

This isn’t that far off… Tua is a good QB, but in the class of QB’s that need a lot of pieces around them to be successful - I think it’s Tier 2/3. So much of the offense is wisely built around Hill. Not just passing but putting him in motion helps the run game significantly.

This is a major stereotyping but I do think he has the “wrestler” mentality. I had several friends like this in HS. Polite and soft spoken but also very serious and discipline about training and focused on a single goal - wrestling. Almost militaristic. Not people who fool around. And with this training and success came a certain confidence/arrogance that, if they needed to, they could whip anyone’s ass. In many cases, it was probably true I think this is where he might come off as narcissistic. Interesting point from the Dunne article - one player noted he almost needed to be this way with young team - but maybe not with a more veteran one.

Fair point Scott.

He will most certainly see if he’s salvageable….as a backup QB to the rookie they draft

You’re right…he’s not anywhere near the top of the list for win percentage. My bad

This entire message board is assumptions. What’s your point Mickey? You mean the record that shows he’s the winningest coach in Bills history. Sure seems by his record that he’s “blatantly” not a good coach.

Meh, no one would care Josh wins that game and everyone is pumped he beat KC. No one is saying “buuuuut, the defense couldn't stop KC on the final possession.”