GerstAusGosheim

So you're saying Sean is such a bad coach that even a future hall of fame QB couldn't win a Super Bowl here? Sounds about right.

It's #1 on Sean's legacy if he never wins a Super Bowl. 1: Trading Mahomes pick 2: Breaking 17-year playoff drought 3: Blowing 13 seconds 4: Wasting the Josh/Diggs window with a rookie OC

Let's see if Jahmile Addae can get something out of Elam that John Butler couldn't.

Sean's influence in the draft room and free agency has crippled this team. Defense line draft picks that never pan out Defense tackle signings that are not good enough Multiple average running backs Von miller contract Elam sucks It is totally unacceptable in 2024 with Josh Allen as your QB not to have drafted WRs anticipating this day.

Watch Diggs will win the Super Bowl next year with Texans.

If Diggs spills the beans on :13, this board is going to explode.

This is Sean buying another year. He blew the Josh/Diggs window and he's looking start over.

These are all good points, but you can't say he literally drafted Josh Allen and ignore that he literally traded away Mahomes. He has my respect for turning the franchise around and building a contender. But he has a generational QB and it's time to win.

If Leslie Frazier called the D at the end of :13, Sean would have fired him on the spot. Instead, he returned the following season, and despite having an injury plagued D and the near-death of a player, had the #2 ranked D. When Sean's hand-selected rookie OC only put up 10 points against Cincy with Josh-freaking-Allen as his QB, Leslie got fired. It took Sean another half season to figure out who the real problem was. Sean's D was ranked 12th last season. And now we have a rookie DC.

I will happily and enthusiastically call myself a clueless Bills fan when he wins an actual championship. He blew our best chance in 30 years. Until then, he's just an average coach being carried by a generational QB in many people's eyes.

People still think Frazier called the plays at the end of the game and McDermott didn't confuse the squibb kick call? No wonder Sean still has supporters.

Except that McMeddle took over play calling at the end of the game. Caused confusion on the squibb. And blew the Defensive calls. Shoulda just let the people he hired do their jobs instead of micromanaging one of the worst coaching blunders in NFL history. When you compare Sean's DVOA from 2023 to Leslie's DVOA in 2022 and 2021, sacks went up, but Leslie's overall DVOA rank was higher.

Wild that over 62% think the Bills will at least make the AFC championship game when we couldn't achieve that at our peak when Sean blew :13 and last season when Burrow was out and Mahomes looked human. Given the less talented roster and rough schedule, I just don't see it. I wish I could be this optimistic.

It was a joke. Agree with your first two points. But cannot be certain about the 3rd.

First round Safety

Preparing the fans for a Rd1 Safety

Butler was fired. He's pissed. After Bobby's dad got him the job, he lucked into coaching healthy Poyer, Hyde and Milano in their prime. It's like winning the coaching lottery. Now Bobby's the rising star. And Butler is out.

How? Sean took over play calling and totally blew it.

Cumulative effect. If you're feeling worse about this year's loss it's because we keep losing over and over when it matters. It's insult to injury. Because honestly, there was nothing worse than losing :13.

We lost 13 seconds because of Sean's boneheaded decisions. We lost last year because Sean's hand-selected OC scored 10 points. We lost this year because Sean's D couldn't stop chiefs. Hopefully, he's learned at every step and this team can finally reach its potential.

And Cam Newton was washed up at 30. We have maybe 3-4 years left of Josh being the duel-threat Josh he is today.

Sean's D gave up 3-game winning drives that ended up in losses and almost lost to the Giants as well. His aggressiveness backfired at times. In 2022, Leslie Frazier’s top ranked D went 13-3 missing the following players... Micah Hyde - 15 games Tre White - 11 games Von Miller - 8 Games Christian Benford - 7 games Damar Hamlin - 5 games Jordan Phillips - 4 games Jordan Poyer - 4 Games Gregory Rousseau - 3 Games Tremain Edmunds - 2 Games Ed Oliver - 2 Games Daquan Jones - 1 Game (Bengals Playoff!) Boogie Basham - 1 Game Dane Jackson - 1 Game

The answer to this poll depends entirely on how many more years Sean is allowed to waist Josh's prime.

Trying to be objective here. He also had Poyer and Hyde in their prime when they were fully healthy and available. Then inherited Milano and Tremain Edmunds in their prime. So is he one of our best coaches, or luckiest?

We're numb to Sean blowing playoff games.