I think this is an overreaction. Every situation is going to dictate which "Josh" should play each week. For last night's game, i agree. He probably could've taken off more as long as he can avoid those hits. Yes, our defense was atrocious last night, but mainly because the offense put them in horrible positions. From there, neither side of the ball could gain any true rhythm. Yes, we were missing key defenders on defense, but I think the biggest loss we had last night was the absence of Smoke. Our best defense this year is our offense and it was evident how much they missed Smoke because they were not able to stretch the field. But in response to the original post, Josh doesn't need to be a RB each week. They just need to learn how to adjust when key players are missing.