Logic

I really liked this one. Got a dynamic EDGE, a mauling guard who can compete with Mongo, a CB2 candidate, a returner/gadget guy, developmental 1T, change of pace at running back, and a big nickel/ST ace. This would be the perfect draft, IMO.

Sounds like a trade for Evan Engram is the new speculation. The thought is that Rudolph’s addition to a crowded NYG TE room would’ve made Engram available. Beane and Giants GM Dave Gettelman have a good relationship. Alas, Frelund’s implication that said player is no longer available likely means a trade for Engram is off the table . And thus likely ends Tight End Watch 2021, at least for now.

Thanks for the reply. One point I think you’re overlooking is that they DID sign two free agents at key positions: right tackle and WLB. Had they let those players walk and instead signed an edge player or dynamic offensive player, then sure, they would improve in those areas, but they would then also need a starting tackle and a starting linebacker. Keeping Josh Allen upright and supplying him with weapons is priority one. You and I agree we’d like to see speed added, but no one can say with a straight face that they haven’t given Josh protection and weaponry. If they “only” bring back last year’s offense and add Sanders, well: last year’s offense scored the most points in team history! They scored more PPG than the vaunted Chiefs! So “just” returning that offense? Not so bad. If your position is that you wish they had let Milano and Williams walk and used the money elsewhere, that’s understandable. But in that case, you must at least acknowledge the possibility that losses in talent at right tackle and WLB might not have been easy to replace, and thus might have cancelled out any gains made elsewhere.

As Joe Marino pointed out in Twitter, the best chance the Bills have at significantly improving is for their young, highly drafted players to take a leap. We need more D-line production? Ed Oliver and AJ Epenesa could solve that. We need better run game production? Cody Ford and Moss and Singletary improving could sure give us a boost. More passing game production? Gabriel Davis and Dawson Knox progressing will certainly add to the arsenal. I’d like to see some more moves made, too. But at the end of the day, the Bills were 13-3 against a very tough schedule last year, and they have young players at key positions whose progression could significantly improve the team as a whole. With the money they had to spend this year, I’m just not sure what huge difference makers they realistically could’ve afforded that would push them ahead of the Chiefs. We need our young, premium draft pick players to progress. Oliver, Epenesa, and Edmunds having breakout years alone could be the difference.

I hope you’re right. I’m a Knox believer. I’m a big fan of his. The only problem is that hope is not a strategy. If Knox DOESN’T take a third year leap (or, say, gets injured), then the cupboard is pretty bare at tight end at a time when the Bills championship window is wide open. I just want more talent added to the room. I also think that adding an effective in-line TE would free Knox up to be more of a move TE/matchup nightmare chess piece. Knox can break out AND the Bills can add talent at the position. It’s not “either/or”, it’s “Yes, and...”.

I totally forgot about Zimmer! Dude was balling out at times last year. Watching him chase Tyreek Hill 50 yards downfield was an out of body experience.

Allen, Gentry, Hollister. It’s official: We’re re-creating the 2016 Wyoming Cowboys. I’m guessing our old BBMB friend WYO is a big fan of the move!

I suggest everyone read this: https://www.si.com/nfl/seahawks/.amp/gm-report/seahawks-2021-free-agent-primer-jacob-hollister?__twitter_impression=true *Edit: I see Hapless already quoted this article. I still suggest giving the whole thing a read. Hollister is a move tight end/H-back type. Can play all over the formation. He could be Kroft’s replacement, but he also very well may be GILLIAM’S replacement.

Why? Bills like to go to camp 4-5 deep at TE. Hopefully they still plan to add one or two more players there.

6’4”, 245 LBs. 27 years old. Played with Allen at Wyoming. As long as this isn’t the only move at tight end, I support it. He looks like a younger, cheaper Kroft replacement. Knox, Hollister, Sweeney isn’t enough. I hope they still try to acquire Ertz or draft a guy.

I also think Diggs will put up less catches and yardage than last year, because Sanders and Davis (and hopefully a tight end or two) will eat into his target share. Not a bad thing. Just means the Bills offense will be more balanced and have more mouths worth feeding!

I agree. I think he winds up with a higher QB rating, but less yards and TDs. Still a great year, but less statistically impressive because the Bills run the ball with more success. 4,400 yards passing 33 TDs 9 INTs 370 yards rushing 7 TDs

Bills scouts have met with several such players already, apparently. Dazz Newsome, Jaelon Darden, and D’wayne Eskridge are some that I know of that the Bills have shown interest in. They may well be looking to fill the returner/gadget role via cheap draft labor.

I’ll grant you the former, but you’re only guessing at the latter.

I hope the Bills sign Cordarelle Patterson. KR, PR, RB, Gadget WR. Roster spot efficiency.

I feel bad for Josh Rosen. If Allen is the prime example of “being drafted into the right situation”, Rosen has to be the exact opposite. I wonder what would’ve happened with Rosen if he had been drafted by a good team into a stable structure, and had actually been given protection and weapons and had a coach that believed in him. And to think, I was actually disappointed on draft night when the Bills took Allen instead of Rosen. 😳

If we plan to continue with heavily rotating our d-line, then we need a legitimate backup 3T. Star, Butler, and Harry are all 1Ts. If Atkins is willing to take what the Bills could afford to offer — and maybe after playing in a bad team his whole career, he’s ready to chase a ring — then he’d be a fantastic addition. Whether it’s Atkins or not, the Bills are going to need to add a 3T at some point.

I agree that the Bills think highly of Knox. I also think they want a savvy veteran to come in and teach him from the field. They recently engaged in talks with Greg Olsen, Rob Gronkowski, and Kyle Rudolph. We know they're at least exploring an Ertz trade. Common denominator among these players? Savvy veterans who can block as well as catch. Knox needs help with both the former and the latter. I also think he would be more effective as more of a move tight end/H-Back. Picture him in Reggie Gilliam's role. Bringing in a Zach Ertz would allow Knox to move around the field, providing a matchup nightmare chess piece for Brian Daboll. As much as I think they like Knox, I think this is also something of a "make it or break it" season for him with regards to being an impact starter. Raw or not, this will be his third season, and the Bills championship window is open NOW. The Bills can't put themselves in a position where if Knox DOESN'T put it all together, they've got nothing in the cupboard.

Interesting use of both capitalization and quotation marks there.

I’ve been thinking the Colts might swoop in and get Ertz. They have Carson Wentz, Frank Reich, and a bunch of cap space. Despite all the speculation that Buffalo is the favorite to land him, my money’s on Indy. Bills wind up with Darren Fells. 🙄

It’s early yet.

While I don’t think there’s a chance in hell of Sammy signing here, he DID return kicks in college. https://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/players/sammy-watkins-1.html

Quinn gets it. Being physically in the city of Buffalo does not necessarily mean that one is signing with the Bills, any more than Jessie Pegula taking a ***** in a Michigan Arby’s means we’ve lured Megatron out of retirement.

The only way I could see this making any sense is if he’s open to the idea of returning kicks and punts. Even then...I don’t see it. The culture fit with Diggs, Sanders and Watkins together seems....not good.

Fair, but they already signed Sanders.