I wonder more if the problem isn’t just the evaluators for the franchise but rather the ones pulling the trigger. These scouts just gather data of players, grade them and then it’s assigned to their big board.
For instance if there was a DE in Landon Jackson with a grade of 80 and a WR or OL that had the same what are the selecting for the team? Even further more, if they believe they have a need for a DE and the highest graded one at the time was 80 but a player with a higher grade, 85 per se, was available do they still select the DE?
Ive been on board with most people who say always draft BPA regardless of position (QB excluded).