Kirby Jackson

Jim Kelly doesn’t belong near the list. OJ had 2,000 yards in 14 games. He was historically great. Kelly was historically good. He’s probably a top 25ish QB ever. He’s not a viable answer for the best player to wear a Bills uniform.

They were fine and have been pretty good. They still had 9/111/1 of the 362 passing yards. Shakir was the only WR with more than 1 catch. This conversation was about the wide receivers and not the pass catchers. The receivers have been fine but they are still just okay.

I had Bruce as 1 until about the middle of the season. The positional value of QB is too great. Bruce was ridiculous but for me, it’s Allen.

We are doing this. Who is the best player that the Bills have ever had? Go on record. You can make a case for any of the 3. The “someone else” answer is not reasonable but there for the people who choose to be wrong. The Bills have had great players but there are 3 options as to the “best.”

Allen Brady OL All 3 RBs Ed Oliver

Usually these individual awards are cool but don’t mean much. I don’t look back at Cam or Matt Ryan’s MVP awards & think differently of them because of them. It’ll be different for Allen. So many people thought he’d flop pre-draft that they’ve stuck to their guns. They’ve refused to admit to their mistakes & have spent his career looking to trash him. “Diggs made him.” “He’s a turnover machine.” Hell, even a small group of his peers, voted him the most overrated player in the league. All of this is taking place as he assaults the record book & carries a mediocre roster to Super Bowl contention. This award will give, undeniable validation, to the best player to ever put on a Bills uniform (with all due respect to Bruce).

The Bills are elite at giving teams a chance.

Thought that the Bills would win by 2 scores. This has been impressive. There’s some stuff to clean up but it’s a physical beating. The Bills are really, really good.

Another McDermott masterclass at clock management. He’s incompetent. That’s impossible to take the run off if you planned on trying to score. The order of plays that you should have run there: 1. FG 2. Hail Mary Last anything else (that was the Peterman scramble all over)

It’s an awful sports day. The first Saturday without meaningful football is always depressing. Army & Navy are at least both pretty good but that game is still a “background game” to me. The 1st Saturday with meaningful football is like Christmas. This day is like the day you start taking your decorations down.

I don’t know of anyone that has taken it. I wouldn’t recommend it though because control when leaving is crucial. Coming to the stadium is easy because the times are so staggered. I usually arrive 4:30 hours before kickoff. I can get there in 23 minutes from my house. When the game ends the experience can be vastly different. We have mastered the egress since childhood. You need to be purposeful and swift. I can get home in under 30 minutes while seeing the whole game if done correctly. The second that the game is decided we head to the gate. There are no bathroom stops allowed at that point. Lol, sometimes Jessica struggles with this. If you have to go, use the 2 minute warning. If the game is 1 sided it is much less important as the stadium empties at different times. Park as close to the exit of your lot as you can. Get in your car. Don’t mess around and get into the street. If McKinley is a part of your route home, cut through the parking lot by Wegmans. Get to the Thruway. You won’t regret it. It can legitimately save up to 2+ hours if done correctly. Getting stuck after is the absolute worst. Last tip, absolutely, 100% DO NOT park in a stadium lot. It is a nightmare.

My presale was at 10 AM. Tried to get extra AFC Championship tickets. Yeah, that didn’t happen.

This

I don’t disagree that it’s a terrible job. I was more referring to his ties there and to Louisiana in general. He obviously has a lot of ties to the Bengals as well. I never thought that job would be open but it might be.

Honestly, he reminds me more of Thomas Smith but point taken. I think that the Elam situation is more a function of the organization than him. They are so worried about him getting beaten or penalized that they don’t play him. They are willing to sacrifice his playmaking in exchange for solid play with potentially less mistakes. Personally, it should be situation dependent. Before the game the other day my brother and I were talking about how that was an ideal game to play him a bunch. The Rams crush the zone so you needed to play some man. He can help there. That holds true against teams like the Bengals as well. Put him on Chase for a little while. He will get beaten some but might make a play or 2 that changes the game. It’s better than the death by 1,000 paper cuts from Sunday.

The deal is that the Bills have no idea what to do with him. Elam is a physical, at times handsy, CB that is aggressive playing the ball. The Bills conservative style is an odd fit with him. I suspect that they don’t like that he can get beat and sometimes struggles getting off blocks in the run game. The flipside is that he has the physical tools to match up with great receivers. He will get beat some but also make some plays. The Bills try so hard to “bend but not break” that he ends up not playing. The reality is that he should play some vs. the best receivers. Mirroring Puka the other day would have been nice. I’m confident that he wouldn’t have produced the game he produced otherwise. The Bills are so set on sitting in that soft zone that they can get shredded by slot receivers and TEs. They did. Stafford was the top rated QB in the NFL vs. zone entering the game the other day. The Bills seemingly played it all day and got 1 stop I think (excluding the last series where they were running out the clock). This one goes to coaching.

He’s is the real issue and has been. He’s made way more crucial errors that have cost games than he has shrewd decisions that have stolen games. That being said, I had no issue with accepting the penalty. The Rams were going otherwise. Backing them up was the only way to potentially force a punt. They were never kicking a FG to go up 6. The 1st down sneak is way less forgivable. I was screaming at the TV before they lined up. You HAD to throw 4 times from there. The only chance was to preserve 3 TOs and hope to kick a long FG at the buzzer. That was him not understanding the situation.

You sure about that?

Epenesa is playing as bad of a 1/2 as I can remember a Bills player playing. Horrendous 1/2

SMU it is. For everyone worried that the playoff would water down the regular season and conference championship games, it didn’t. This was exciting.

I think it’ll be Bama. I’m not even sure if I agree or disagree with that. Your points are valid. The only thing that makes me pause is that the committee doesn’t want to set a precedent that losing in a conference championship game could hurt you. Teams will be opting out like players do in bowl games. SMU telling the ACC, “naw, we’re good without playing in your championship game” would’ve had them in the playoff. This will be super interesting.

Not picking on you but this is a GIANT pet peeve of mine. The backup QB role isn’t about, “can the team win the Super Bowl if the starter is out?” While that has happened a few times before (Foles, Hostetler, etc), that isn’t the purpose. If Allen were to miss 4 weeks(ish), could the Bills win 2 or 3 of those games to maintain their playoff seeding? If you’re looking at a backup QB any other way, you’re doing it wrong. Mitch is okay but I liked him more before the move to Pittsburgh. Tyrod would be the perfect backup for this team but don’t know his contract situation. You should always be drafting and developing a guy as well. You need to do that every 2 or 3 years. I am not talking about some guy with no physical skills like Peterman or Fromm. Those guys didn’t have the physical traits to ever get better. Don’t buy game managers from college in the late rounds. You can throw a rock and find backups around the league like that. Buy physical tools and hope to develop them. Riley Leonard is a name that comes to mind. He’s 6’4” with a good arm. He’s skinny now but maybe you can bulk him up some. He has a high school track background as well. Its worth a 5th and a couple of PS years to see if he can become a player.

What you say?