All good points buddy.
It doesn't sound like we are that far off in terms of our judgement on him. Sounds like you have a slightly higher opinion on him than me.
I am by no means saying he sucks or anything like that.
I think there are times where he can absolutely dominate a football game, (like last week) and then have times where he looks completely lost out there. (Like against KC last year)
I think the Bills picking up his 5th year option kind of reflects that as well.
To me it kind of reflects that they "like" him, he's young, he's got great potential, he can dominate some football games, but he also hasn't done it enough consistently to warrant the big contract extension yet.
Would you agree with that assessment?