NewEra

Hilarious. I bet if you go through my post history and look at the eye roll emojis- out of maybe 500 total eye rolls, 475 of them would be him.

If he shows upside, I would. 4 year rookie contract. Do you have any thoughts on Austin? I think the depth of this CB draft class pushed him down and we got a steal. I really like his potential as a zone corner. Not so much man. I think the rule changes could have a big impact on KOs and the overall worth of KO coverages. Which would make Neals main worth revolve around punts….. and we punt less than anyone.

Rick Dennison. Awful

I’m not saying he has to be an elite gunner. Just competent. But I have no clue regarding his ST play, I was just throwing it out there. the new rules, imo, are the only reason I think Neal might be cut. I don’t think he will be…. McD definitely loves his ST only players…. But I’d rather keep austin, a guy that i think could be a CB in this league over a guy that can only play. The new rules reinforce my thinking on that. I realize that someone would have to step up and be a competent gunner in order to cut him, I just think KO unit players took a big hit on the rule change. I’d be all for keeping him if he could play some corner or safety. The fact that he couldn’t play over Cam Lewis speaks volumes to me

I thought he was around 8-10 last year. This years injuries were too much to overcome, but the playoff performance Vs Cinci was dreadful. That’s 2 out of 3 years that coached absolute stinkers in season ending losses. The 13 second game, he coached fine…. Until he made the biggest coaching blunder in franchise history. Making that 3 straight seasons in which season ending losses were on his head more than anyone else’s. jmo, but he’s right around 10 Reid belichick shanahan mcvay tomlin pederson harbaugh carroll taylor sirriani that’s my top 10 in no particular order except the last 2 are 9-10z. I’d put Taylor and Sirianni ahead of McD atm If we put up another stinky stinker in a season ending afc playoff loss, I’d be all for replacing him with Ben Johnson. I wouldn’t want to fire him just to fire him. Only if we had a particular target to replace him with. Ben Johnson is that guy to me right now.

He also proved that he could have success with a terrible roster (and an even worse OC). im not saying he’s great, but this list is a joke and not even close to fair. It’s pure click bait for Bills Mafia

Didn’t take long to figure out who you were talking about. Do yourself a favor and put him on ignore. No reason to waste your time with that bro.

I don’t recall the nature of his injuries, but he was healthy for the most part in college iirc. I think it’s great that health is the only mark against him. 1.77M 😂

Lol. Maybe 😔

He has a top 3 QB and has been eliminated by the other top 3 QBs in each of the 3 seasons in which our QB has been elite. 🤷🏻‍♂️ we were decimated by injuries last season and our team wasn’t good enough in Josh’s first elite season. He flopped 13 secs, a borderline fireable offense, but I thought his track record was good enough to keep him.

No arguments there. I just don’t see what that has to do with this list being fair.

I just said why we’d move him. Austin, if he performs well. there aren’t enough cb roster spots. Tre Elam Taron Dane Benford/Austin Neal makes it for ST (sadly) I don’t think our S depth is great ans of now with Damars uncertainty. Our top 3 are great, but who are the guys after them? One died on the field. Another is the worst player on the roster. Another is a ST guy named Zayne. Our top 3 safeties are all free agents at the end of the year. If Damar returns to form, I agree, we’re set. Just not sure that’s going to happen. Benford has 3 years left under contract making the minimum. If he could step in next 2 seasons as a starter and play well, that’s a win win win. I don’t think he’ll be more than CB4 on this team the next 2 years. I would love for Austin to be able to take Neals spot on ST. Neal brings nothing to the table on D imo.

As a bama hater, I’ve always hated Harris. Then he goes to the pats and saves his best games for the Bills. More hate!! that said, I think he’s a perfect compliment to cook. There are better backs for sure, but for the price and the style he plays, I think we hit a home run with his downhill ability. Just stay healthy.

Until proven otherwise? Wth are you talking about? has it been proven that Staley, Smith, McConnell, mcdaniel are better? Please, explain. Thanks in advance.

Let’s not act like mcdermott didn’t have success without Josh allen. He did. He made the playoffs with a tank team. As if that means nothing. Who’s better, Tua or Tyrod? Who’s better cousins or Tyrod? Both teams had MUCH more talent that McD had in 2017. No comparison. Mariota = Tyrod. I’ll give it a push for QB play. And McD made the playoffs….. smith. Back to back 7-10 records. That deserves to be ahead of mcdermotts 62-35 record? You can’t be serious. I think smith is a good coach and he’s done well considering the talent in his team…. But there’s no way he should be ranked ahead of mcdermott at this point. I agree that mcdermott is on the hot seat this season. Not because he’s not a good coach. But because he’s hasn’t been good enough to coach Josh Allen to a Super Bowl W. do you really think McDermott is should be ranked outside of the top 20?

2021 being the year in which our OL got destroyed on almost every play? That same game where hill and Kelce went for 22-290-2? There’s a big difference between being “more than good enough to make the SB” and “should have made the Super Bowl”. We had a dam good team that year, but the chiefs were clearly the better team. They handled us easily twice that season. Sure, we could have beaten them, any given Sunday…. But the team that “should have” made the Super Bowl, made the Super Bowl. That wasn’t us. KC was better that year. I agree, we should’ve at least made the AFCCG the following season but our 13 second coaching gaffe ended us. but we still had to beat Cinci. This was the one season I feel it’s ok to say we should’ve made the SB. Last year, I thought we had the best team in the league, but injuries derailed our season. We had no chance with the team we put on the field vs Cinci.

Should have been to the Super Bowl 2 times? Which two?

To me, the argument made is why he shouldn’t not be top 10. But not to be top 20. That’s just insane.

It really is a joke. What’s even more of a joke is that some Bills fans are ok with him being behind these guys that have done nothing. i think mcdermott is closer to 10 than to 20. To have him 22 looks like click bait playing on bills mafias internet prowess. He knows that one ranking will generate its fair share of clicks.

Yeah that would be the clincher. We all know that McB will still put an emphasis on ST, but I’m hoping that ST doesn’t matter as much as it did before the rule change.

I agree with Austin. I think he has a real shot to make the team. He could push Benford to safety and possibly Damar off the team. Cam Lewis 👋🏻 byyeeeee

He made the playoffs with Tyrod Taylor @ QB in a season in which everyone thought we were tanking. Shady and Clay were our most targeted receivers. Zay, Deonte Thonpson, KB, Andre Holmes. That team had a better record than Mike Mcdaniels who had a loaded roster and a better QB. Mike Tolbert.

You think it’s fair that Brandon Staley, Arthur Smith, McConnell and Mcdaniel should be ranked ahead of him? There are more on the list that we can question….. but those 4 guys have no right at the moment

why are you having this conversation? I made a post. My SWF told me that I needed to temper my expectations. I disagree. My hopes and expectations will have no effect on anything. Who’s expecting 140 1200 12? My expectations are that he will be a great player.

Thanks bro. When I saw his reply I thought to myself, “this will be a colossal waste of my time. It’s not worth it”. was it? 🤣