NoSaint

plenty as in just above the bare minimum or plenty as in among the most in the league Also, how’s that stress looking if Josh is only minimally running?

I don’t think he’s an all pro out there but I see worse play around the league regularly - and at times right here. the refusal to use him is… odd.

essentially even here you are saying they are in the batch of “average” pass catchers and I think we can agree that Josh is probably a decent multiplier for what we think of those guys ratings. the classic is cook-Kincaid-Coleman-Samuel really ever going to be talked about as top third of the league if not for thinking you have an absolutely elite match up nightmare at qb? If you sub Josh for even a middle of the pack cousins/tua type of player at qb suddenly the group is a wreck.

less than 700 yards as a wr is a tough one. It could be a sign of talent but just as easily there are also a metric ton of guys that given the right reps could pull 500-700 yards because “someone has to catch the ball” and even terrible offenses put up thousands of passing yards.

he’s tough, and can play teams, and is a fine enough depth Wr…. And most importantly some of his pay was guaranteed which would be a tie breaker amongst some other similar guys.

And for what amounts to nearly zero effort on his part - rehab his image a bit by showing up in his most charismatic form for a couple days instead of forcing his team to answer questions (and him act shocked that he will also be asked them later)

Ive always said if a guy throws zero picks in practice that’s kind of a concern itself. You can’t be an idiot out there all the time but sometimes you have to actually take the learning reps and that’s by far the best place to see what you can and can’t get away with, right? obviously you want to see lots of success but having zero fails means you probably aren’t pushing yourself much either. There’s a balance there.

yea you have to be a real jerk to change your opinion of a guy off an OTA practice having a couple errant balls. if you thought he was a bum with major accuracy issues I get feeling some confirmation if he’s sailing passes but…. Pretty complete prospect having a mediocre practice l? Pfffffft.

yea it feels like the solution was a true minor league and not leaning into universities being premium sports entertainment meccas i get the toothpaste is out of the tube and has been for decades but…. It’s not a particularly reasonable approach to shove these two pieces together under one umbrella

my least favorite recent was banning resale below face for an event that wasn’t sold out. Like couldn’t use any other vendor and had to be at or above cost for a GA show… fun eating the cost of those tickets when plans changed

I do not believe those attendee numbers to be true but… im assuming it’s counting the same fan about 8 times over the weekend going into different events and most of those are locals

I should have been clear I was agreeing on McGovern

I haven’t been super excited about the center situation but of the question marks I do think he is one that could actually end up emphatically filling the hole he is slotted up for. It’s no guarantee but he’d be the least shocking of the safety, center, wr1, etc… to actually hit it out of the park

well shoot- if we are getting all of their best years

we were 13 seconds away from playing in the game to get to the game…. while I agree they had a shot…. They couldn’t hold on for 13 seconds so 120 more minutes is quite the journey left to reach the goal

We are halfway through this ride and haven’t come particularly close. At some point that’s got to be a problem.

sounds like you are a huge fan of Josh

Can I say the oddest part was a 2 year design process to pick which era pants and which era jersey to wear?

so small Rapp will miss and kill a teammate the true plan is revealed

going to likely be on the street in September no matter where he goes but at the 90th roster spot beane took a swing for a surprise at least I guess

plus this idea that everyone has to take a stance on everything instead of accepting we don’t know much about most of it

yea seemed pretty nervous but totally out of his element and going right out of the gate so not a lot to index against. I thought he did well for a non comedian

or I keep saying - heaven forbid Samuel rolls an ankle in a preseason game and misses September? Week 1 could get real thin real fast if Coleman is even slightly a project and either Shakir or Samuel miss any early reps for 10% of the cost and as wr4 instead of wr2

there’s a section of the board that likes to be razor thin

There’s a reality that pass catchers will miss games and having some depth isn’t the worst. if prefer another viable wr but Knox is a good player There’s a reality that pass catchers will miss games and having some depth isn’t the worst. if prefer another viable wr but Knox is a good player