He had a great year with Chip K. and looked rough with with Rams. On their playoff run and in the Super Bowl he outplayed Tom* Brady*.
Id still get a rookie if we went after him, but the guy deserves some credit.
There was a lot of criticism from the national media on the Lynch hire in SF. I think he's done a hell of a job and that team is going to surprise next season, even if they don't land Sherman.
I keep going back to this as well. They picked this years class over last years. Now, I don't think they expected to make the playoffs no matter what they say, but I am still expecting them to get one of the top 4 guys.