Yup. As they should be.
Yeah, throwing for 5,000+ and 4,700+ yards and 48 and 44 TDs back then was amazing. But those were major outliers for him as he averaged about 23 TDs a season (games started, removing final season) around those 2 years.
That's what I've been saying. Anyone who says "McD needs to be fired" never has an answer for "who will replace him?" I'm not even sure who among the active HCs (as you said, Reid isn't leaving KC/coming here) I'd take. McVay? Taylor?
And it's amazing Josh is annually on this list given his first 2 seasons, where he was unpolished as a passer and had poor offenses around him. And barring injury, he should remain the QB with the most TDs in X seasons for the rest of his career.