dave mcbride

To echo GunnerBill, Geisicki can’t block and isn’t really a TE.

Not really in terms of a pick spent on projected performance and value.

Last year’s top pick was … Stefon Diggs, who ended up being the leading receiver in the entire league.

The browns did it too in 2016. Uncompetitive through the first 14 games (especially down the stretch) and once they clinched #1 after 14 games, they all of a sudden became competitive in the final two games. As for randomness, I hear you, but I am only arguing for this approach for the first round. The worst team would pick first in rounds 2-7, and football is a sport where those later rounds really matter with regard to producing good players (unlike say the NBA).

It’s like you didn’t even follow that team that year. They never worked to replace Manning with even a moderately decent backup. They knew a generational talent was coming out and rolled with a truly terrible QB. This is actually common knowledge.

Worked out great for the Colts with Luck — multiple playoff appearances and no losing records. The 2010 Panthers are another example—totally non-competitive down the stretch (tons of blowouts) and they end up with Newton.

Give me time and I am quit sure I could find a dozen instances of it for you. How do you think the Colts ended up with Luck?

Tanking happens all of the time. Maybe not this year — largely because there is no top qb or even a consensus number one pick — but there are tons of instances of it.

Because every year tanking becomes a story, and a) it’s boring and b) it involves teams moving away from competing. It’s tedious, bad entertainment, and bad sports. I’ve felt this way for decades. Good sports is about fierce competition, which is why we’re entertained.

No because the league revenues go up. That is what drives it, not teams overpaying.

Simple solution: no weighting, and the bottom seven teams have an equal chance at the number one pick. It won’t solve inequality — some teams are simply going to be better than others, and I think you’r emisunderstanding parity anyway — but if you are the worst team in week 15 and have a 43 percent chance to be drafting in the 5-7 slot, then you might prioritize getting your team to learn how to win rather than resting starters and making weak calls—i.e., tanking. Tanking, which clearly happens, is a bad sporting event. I’d rather watch public access television at 3 am. That’s a good thing, Don’t signal that you’re going to fully reward abject failure. I’ve never disagreed with you more strongly! The current system is terrible. It’s also not going to last, fwiw. I’d bet money on it. I feel like the status quo bias preference is very, very strong in this thread.

I went to the one before (at the Rose Bowl), and I was not confident at halftime for that one!

They really had no chance in that game - the Bills were up by two scores anyway with basically no time left. It didn’t really affect the outcome at all.

I advise watching the final SB to halftime, declaring victory with a 13-6 win, and then getting the hell out. Like Vietnam. It works for me.

One thing I just discovered — Gase has very deep roots with Nick Saban going back to his college years at Michigan State. That’s why this make some sense. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adam_Gase

Di Fara is pretty great (their Sicilian, that is), although I haven’t been in years. The thing is, there are four dedicated pizza places and two Italian restaurants that make their own pizza (as part of a broader menu) that are all within a 3-10 minute walk from my house in Park Slope, and they are all excellent in their own ways. So I pretty much stick to them. Roberta’s in Williamsburg is the bomb (and my favorite). I actually took a cooking class with the two owners about 8 years ago and can make a pretty fair version of their pie myself. I learned a ton about the importance of ingredients. For instance, for the sauce, you gotta use San Marzano whole tomatoes (no other type is nearly as good) and puree them yourself. They said that all tomato companies basically save the best tomatoes for the whole-tomato cans and relegate the second-rate ones to the puree/crushed tomato cans. I did a taste test afterward, and they were absolutely right. Same thing about using the right flour (00 super-fine mixed with good bread flour) and mozzarella. Thankfully, there is a great Italian store up the block that makes their own incredible mozzarella. Lombardi’s on Spring Street and Grimaldi’s in Dumbo are both fantastic too. Long lines, however. Di Fara has long lines too, but if you get there early on the weekend (10:45 am or so) it’s not too bad. I haven’t tried the other ones you mention. Sounds like I should!

If you come, don’t hesitate to ask for recs!

Hondo, I have lived in Brooklyn for a quarter century but grew up loving pizza in Buffalo. I have to report that pizza in NYC is ... a LOT better than pizza in Buffalo. I don't even enjoy eating the latter anymore, although we always end up with Bocce's on Thanksgiving weekend. I certainly don't DISLIKE Bocce's or La Nova, but it's only a moderate cut above the pizza you can get in anywhere USA. I did live in LA for 8 years, and the average pizza remains terrible there. Buffalo is definitely a better pizza town than LA. The flipside is that the Mexican in LA is out of this world. I do like Chicago pizza a lot, but my view on that is that it's really a different food group and shouldn't be compared with regular pizza.

I'd far prefer it to be Josh vs. Trevor Simien, Jalen Hurtz, or Cam Newton.

If you don’t like the actual Promo the Robot, you must have a sad life. Also, it’s not as if you’re name is referring to something more recent. And Torquemada was a cruel villain who sent tons of innocent people to their deaths 500 or so years ago. Basically, a genuine villain in history. 😎

Flores is doing some really strange things now. Once you file a suit, don’t issue charges in the media that you know probably can’t proven (re Belichick *probably* advising the Giants to look favorably upon Daboll—which is not problematic anyway). Apparently he approached the law firm he’s using rather than the reverse, but that firm’s filing ain’t doing him any favors. That filing is a throw it all against the wall and see what sticks approach. He took down Jersey/AFC in epic fashion in 2000, and now he’s taking out Jersey/NFC in epic fashion. Rabid Boston fans gotta love it. Who’s next? The Yankees? The Knicks?

At the risk of comparing apples and oranges (baseball and football in this case), Knox strikes me as a player with a good FIP relative to his ERA: https://www.sportingnews.com/us/mlb/news/what-is-fip-era-pitching-baseball-mlb-stats-statistics-advanced-sabermetrics/d5p48p6z6us51lqbo0wvgigto. There are things he can't control, like how many passes are thrown to him and what the winds are like in Buffalo in any given game. But when called upon, he makes plays, including explosive ones. In other words, I think the trajectory points upward.

Good thread. I'd also add that you have to look a little beyond the numbers and look at what he offers physically. He's really fast for a TE and a true matchup problem. That perspective is important, I think, because I think it may tell you more about future productivity. I'm not saying he's going to be Kelce, but he's also not going to be Scott Chandler. He's just more talented than the latter, and frankly more physically gifted than most TEs in the league. In other words, there's real upside with him with regard to future growth.

This. Your backup is a guy who can get you to 2-2 over a four game stretch (or 3-3, but you get my point). Trubisky was ideal this year, but he's likely a goner. Fitz can do that provided the hip injury he had didn't basically end his career. It may have; we just don't know.

Well, one of those losses to MSU was one of the most ridiculous losses ever (the blocked punt one). Harbaugh coached well in that game and lost on a complete fluke in a game that Michigan had in the bag (btw, my wife went to MSU).