HomeskillitMoorman

The Giants should put in Barkley. DeVito is just non-competitive. I can't believe after watching this guy at Syracuse that he's starting NFL games.

So can we hire Ben Johnson already? He's doing this with Goff while McD and Dorsey don't know what to do with Josh Allen.

Dude...you're getting a Dell

Haha they're going to gift this to the Bengals

That was a Josh pick from Burrow. Why force that?

That’s why McD blowing it 2 years ago with 13 seconds just hurts that much more. It was the beginning of the end.

We should sell teams on a buy one get one free package. If you take McD, we’ll pay for Dorsey’s salary and you get him for free.

No...but he also skirted that question, as always. He's got answers, many I don't agree with, but he's got answers for every question except the big Daddy Trump one. Whatever amount he's risen in the polls from has basically been from the DeSantis pool. He's afraid to go after Trump and can't give a compelling reason for why a Trump voter should vote for him instead when he calls Trump the best president we've ever had. The whole "because I'm young" thing doesn't work because they just say "OK, we'll vote for you in '28 then and we bring back the GOAT for '24". He's not wrong about so many of these other people being puppets...but it is hypocritical when he is one himself for Trump.

So I understand the position from Conservatives on abortion even though i don't agree... But I don't get their thing with weed at all. It's not even as bad for you as drinking alcohol and alcohol leads to many things that weed doesn't. Also if they claim it's not a big deal...why not just let it go and legalize it? If you're so annoyed that you lose votes because of it, why hang on to it for really no reason whatsoever?

It's a great post and I've been pounding this in for a while now. I do think more and more people are finally waking up here though.

You think McD being uninvolved in the offense is an excuse, I don't. That's what this comes down to. He's the HEAD COACH, he's not the defensive coordinator. The offense IS also his problem whether he is involved or he has the wrong people running it. That's what you don't seem to understand. You think McD should be completely absolved for whatever happens on that side of the ball. It's like you don't understand what a Head Coach is. Also, that very idea that McD should have no clue whatsoever on what's happening on offense is flawed in it of itself. You think they go into a game and he's just totally surprised but what the offense is doing? That he has no idea what the gameplan is or what they're working on? That's a huge problem if that's the case. And if he does know and has done absolutely nothing to influence any kind of change, that's his fault too. It all comes back to the Head Coach, that's why they are the Head Coach. And Dorsey was here last year, McD had a chance to evaluate him. He brought him back. Again, on McD. All of it is. I would love for you to explain how I want Dorsey "absolved" when I'm calling for both to be fired. I also wanted Dorsey out after last year. I don't have a bias here, you do. You're willing to bend and twist whatever it takes to hold McDermott unaccountable. The guy hasn't put in any work to improve his shortcomings for over 6 years now and still makes the same exact mistakes and is now completely in over his head when his roster and QB aren't bailing him out anymore. Do you think as a complete team that we're getting better and climbing upwards?

Not my first choice but over McD? In a second.

Agreed, but it should be fire McD and Dorsey.

It's HIS coordinator! Who imposed Dorsey on McDermott? Who let Dorsey come back? You still act like McDermott is just a helpless, innocent bystander. If he doesn't like something, he can change it. He's the Head Coach. And if he doesn't know how to change anything on that side of the ball, he should not be a Head Coach. A Head Coach is a different job from a coordinator. You DO have to be involved in all facets of the game and be knowledgable about all facets of the game. You keep doing this over and over again where you think McD and Dorsey are isolated issues. They are not. They are one in the same.

The defense was lucky the Bengals shot themselves in the foot a few times too. Everyone knew on that last drive there was no way we were getting that stop. If they went pedal to the metal they would've blown the doors off us.

This is such a strange argument. Do you think things are getting better here? Would you not want to try to get someone who can even possibly take you over the top when you have a guy that has shown he can't do it and whose team and program has been in decline? Yes, there's always a risk of getting worse. But what are you afraid of losing here?

Either that or he let Dorsey do it himself and didn't interject. I don't even care which one it was to be honest, I don't see how either of those doesn't fall on the Head Coach ultimately. It's the same way I felt when people would say Frazier's defense was too soft. I completely agreed...but in the end that problem is on the Head Coach. He isn't just a helpless, innocent bystander. He's the Head Coach for a reason and he's showing us he can't handle the responsibility especially when he has a struggling coordinator. We've seen it multiple times now and it's even worse when it's not on "his" side of the ball. That tells you he's not cut out to be a Head Coach, at least not a championship caliber one.

OK, then you're getting what you want right now. Enjoy it.

I'm willing to risk getting worse if it means we have the chance to get better. Which with an elite talent at QB, we absolutely do. I'm also wiling to take that risk when we know we will never win it all with this current head coach.

McD is not above throwing someone under the bus. See 13 seconds. He's not some honorable leader that took the fall. He basically told us it was someone else's fault for not relaying what he supposedly wanted, if we believe that. I'm not sure I do, but either way he did throw the old ST coach under the bus to everyone.

What success? We made it to an AFC Championship 3 years ago and it's been downhill ever since, including the 13 seconds debacle. Do you believe things are getting better here?

You think this the mark of a good head coach, a guy who didn't ask his OC until after the game why he stopped doing something that worked??? McDermott is not just a defensive coordinator, he is the Head Coach. This idea you guys have that the head coach is an innocent bystander and has no ability to interject during the game and be part of the overall philosophy is either dumb or some kind of apologetics propaganda for McDermott. Again, it's the same nonsense people would do when Frazier was here. "It's not McDermott's fault, he doesn't run the defense!" As if there is absolutely nothing he can do if he sees things he doesn't like. It's on McD if something happens that doesn't make sense to him and he doesn't do anything to interject or make a change. This is his team, it's not Dorsey's. If he can't handle it, which he very clearly can't, he needs to go. Not just Dorsey, that doesn't solve the biggest problem.

If McD's doing the right thing, he'd resign. It's like you guys don't believe in responsibility for the Head Coach for when they not only hire the wrong guy, but keep him for another season and do absolutely nothing to change anything. There is no reason to trust McD to make the next hire. He is completely in over his head, you can see it right now. He doesn't have answers for anything, and then they stop doing the few things that actually work. It's complete madness and he's at the head of it.

He should, it's McD's own failure. He's not a martyr. He created this mess.

But then you proceed to want to let him completely off the hook for it. That's what I'm pointing out. It's like the Curb Your Enthusiasm episode where Jerry Seinfeld comes on and they're making fun of how people say something that's factual and then follow it up with "having said that" and say the complete opposite. That is exactly what you're doing. McDermott is the one who needs to go along with Dorsey. That's his guy and this went on for more than a season. It's the same nonsense where you guys would skirt responsibility with him and put it on Frasier. That was his guy and he had him stick around for years, and he had the power to step in and change anything he didn't like, just like he does with this offense or philosophy. It's such a joke how you guys will throw out all rationality when it comes to McDermott. He is the big problem here. We will never win a championship with him here.