Hindsight is 20/20. Floyd is cheaper to resign, but at what point do age and injuries render him no longer valuable? Same applies to AJ. Players typically don’t last 5 seasons unless they are elite. Signing AJ gives us someone for 4-5 more prime age seasons, so if the choice is you can only sign AJ or Floyd take AJ.
These 1 year deals are on vets are great. I’d try to get Floyd and Jones back on fair incentive laden deals. The veteran players we want are the guys who want to play for championships on a fair market value contract with bonus incentives.