Nobody is saying that. But that offense this year is severely limited by the weaponary. No surprise at all one of the INTs came with him trying to throw an out to the boundary and only having a small slot receiver out of position out there. It kinda went through McConkey's hands but it wasn't on him. Herbert mailed the throw slightly but you get away with that if you have a legit outside receiver there. The Quinten Johnston pick is a bust. Sunk cost at this stage but it's over he isn't turning that around. He can't separate, has questionable hands and plays smaller than his size.
He has never been Josh Allen. And anyone making that comparison at any point is silly. He also played poorly last night. But Harbaugh and Roman are running a prehistoric scheme and have one playmaker who is a rookie slot receiver. His situation in 2024 was the worst in the league weapons wise.