GunnerBill

I think based on going to get DK they arguably should have.

Yes but their strengths and what Rodgers can still do well are not aligned. They need a deep ball thrower because neither of them have diverse route trees. And ARod's deep ball has really fallen off.

Thing is DK and Pickens are outside deep ball guys. That is the bit of Rodgers's game I think has most dropped off.

I agree, that is my take on him too. On the bits of his film where you do see him in tighter alignment he is noticeably less dynamic in his get off and there isn't a ton of pass rush plan there. I see him as someone who certainly early is going to be a situational rusher who you just bring in and line up at 9T on 3rd and longs and go Quarterback hunt. The Bills traditionally don't take those guys early. They took Javon Solomon last year who you could say was similar but he was what, a 5th rounder? He will find the transition easier if he goes to a 3-4 team in my view, but I wouldn't hate the Bills taking a shot.

I don't think DK has ever actually dispelled those concerns. He IS a one trick pony. Has been his entire NFL career. He is just elite at that trick and so it hasn't mattered. His success rate on anything other than go routes, post routes and crossers - i.e. routes that require very little change of direction and no short area quickness - is way below average. I think @HappyDays is right to say the number of profiles of that type who succeed is relatively small compared to the ones that fail. I think if you crunched the numbers that would be true, even compared to general success / fail rates. On Thornton particularly.... I haven't really done any kind of deep dive on him as yet, so I don't have a super strong position to speak from. I do think the speed and size is a bit leading to swoony eyes at this stage. He looks pretty raw, but as I say I need to properly get into his film still.

I am sure they will. McDaniels' offense works inside to out in any event.

Yea I disagree. I think Mara was the driving force in that extension. I think he wanted Jones back more than both his GM and his coach. I don't think Schoen and Daboll "wanted him out". They were between a rock and a hard place. Their over achievement year 1 left them without a chance to drsft a guy and Jones was out of contract. Given the owner was badgering to keep him I think they came to the view that was the least bad option. I also think Mara knows he screwed up and that is why Schoen and Daboll are still there. Out of guilt. I don't believe Daboll ever thought he could turn Daniel Jones into Josh Allen. Nope. Not unless there is a different Head Coach at least. I think the relationship with Sean was pretty frayed that final season, having been by all accounts good before that. And even though if Brady goes Josh might campaign for it.... McDermott with another playoff loss would be on the hotseat. He isn't gonna bring in a local guy, who still has some cache with some of the fanbase, who the star QB loves.... cos if things go south you might just have hired your own replacement.

Not really. Douglas is totally toasted. He was brutal last season. All those worrying about Dane Jackson starting for us in 2025.... and they are right to btw.... might want to reflect that it could even be an upgrade on 2024 Douglas. He sucked. Cooper, maybe he is done too, maybe it was the wrist... but sounds like Bills staffers have been telling people he is done. Maybe in the hope that if he is still sitting out there post draft we would bring him back on a cheap deal? Or maybe because they really do think he is done.

If they got Troy on day 3 I'd be fine with that. What I don't want them to do is leave superior options on the table days 1 and 2 because they are reaching to fill holes. If the top receivers in each round are gone before they pick, fine, don't force it. But equally don't force corner or defensive line either. BPA at WR - CB - DE round 1, then the same with the first second rounder. Then at that point before their second second rounder take stock, look at the positions you have managed to address and consider the depth of what is remaining at DT and whichever one of the three premium spots you haven't addressed. My suspicion based on the class is DT will be the deepest remaining spot.... but equally if there is a DT with a round 2 grade there at #62 don't pass on him for a 3rd round grade at another spot.

Albert Breer I think is the only national reporter who has alluded to it. But there are lots of rumours behind the scenes and it was John Mara who the day after the playoff exit the first year with Daboll, with Jones and impending free agent declared to the media "we have our franchise Quarterback" and then on the day the deal was signed he was the one ringing Jones's camp directly. I am not arguing that he was overruling Schoen and Daboll who were desperate not to sign him. But I think this was more than just an owner saying "I support bringing Daniel back" I think he was actively campaigning in the organisation for it. Their relationship has been described as father - son like.

Nah I believe he was actively pushing them to do it.

Yea I think the Giants have been worse. I know the Jets have the longest playoff drought but they didn't draft a running back number 2 in a strong Quarterback draft only to then come back in a weak QB draft the next year and take a 3rd round talent 6th overall. The Jets results might have been worse (although total W-L is close I think) and the Browns (Watson) have made the single worst decision but nobody has consistently screwed the process as bad as the Giants over the past decade.

Yea. I think Cook does make a difference over Motor and Moss because they are both backup level running backs. We thought for a couple of years backup + backup = starter. If you were comparing it to say Najee Harris or someone like that it makes minimal difference. Agree totally with this. Don't count myself in that. I was a defender of the DeJean idea last year. While my preference was a receiver I thought DeJean was a stud and he was my 2nd BPA going into day 2.

This was after the cap increase had been communicated. There was still a gap between Spotrac and Beane on how far over the Bills were.

Yes, but they have been the worst run franchise in the league since about 2014.

I mean technically they did. But it was at the owner's instruction. I don't think they are drafting a QB at #3 now. They have signed Jameis and Russ. Would be odd to sign two bottom end starting level vets if you plan to draft a guy. That normally signals a "we are gonna let these guys compete".

Imagine being a Giants fan from the moment they forced out Coughlin. It has been a total ***** show. Ben McAdoo, Pat Shurmer, Joe Judge, Brian Daboll. Gettlemen and Schoen. But ownership deserves a TON of blame too. They are a disastrous mess of a franchise.

Yea we know Spotrac and Beane were $6m apart at the Combine. Spotrac at that stage was projecting the Bills $10m over the cap and Beane was asked about it in his presser and said "right now we are about $4m". You can speculate why that difference was, but I think it is fair to say they were working on slightly different assumptions.

I wouldn't say third most talented. Diggs was still plenty talented. Third most explosive, sure. He was, last season, a guy who you say "I'm fine him having 8 catches because they will be for 10 yards a pop and not hurt me" whereas go back 3 years if Diggs had 8 catches he probably had 150 yards and 2 touchdowns and had wrecked your gameplan. Whether he is still the guy he even was in Houston is the question on the back of the ACL. And you are right to say it is different being a productive slot when you have explosive guys outside compared to when you have nothing outside and teams can key in on you.

You are still looking at version 1. But I disagree on Ezeiruaku having elite upside. I don't see much ceiling there. To me he is already kinda close to his maximum. High floor, kinda low ceiling. However, in version 2 you will see he doesn't even make it to the Bills' first round pick. Equally, if I was doing a second round now I wouldn't take JTT there either.

He was still a pretty productive slot receiver last year in Houston pre-injury. I don't think he was finished. He could still separate laterally he just couldn't separate vertically anymore. Whether you pay a 31 year old receiver who had lost his fastball and basically become a slot even before his ACL $23m AAV for three years....? Yea only if you are a bad team with more money than sense. My guess is Stef will do okay for them. 600 to 750 yards and 4 or 5 touchdowns. But he won't perform up to that contract.

They were certainly at a talent disadvantage vs the Eagles but they were thorougly and utterly outcoached too. On both sides of the ball. Reid was awful. It was like in the first half he was trying to call plays that played straight into what the Eagles were doing. There was some adjustment second half but it was too late. I agree that if they were going to win that Superbowl they had to win the coaching battle to overcome the superior talent. They lost it resoundingly.

For sure familiarity plays a part in the Bills - Chiefs matchups. The Bills caught them on the hop in the regular season with all the man coverage but when they tried it again in the playoffs Mahomes and Reid were prepared and shredded it. But man.... watching the Superbowl the Chiefs had no answers coaching wise. It was like they defeated us and then spent two weeks with their feet up.

But it is flat our bizarre that they ran plays against the Bills in the AFCCG that they hadn't run all season long. Five of them on offense including the one that finally iced the game. Maybe they did on D as well I don't know I only have the number for their O. And then when they couldn't move the ball basically at all for a half they ran zero new plays against the Eagles in the Superbowl. I am not claiming conspriacy or anything but far from playing the Chiefs being the Bills Superbowl it actually feels the other way around. The Chiefs put more effort into beating us than they did into trying to win a third consecutive Lombardi. They definitely outcoached us in the AFCCG (although they out executed us too). Probably their biggest coaching win vs us in the playoffs since the first AFCCG. But it was like they threw everything at the Bills and had nothing left for Philly.

That in itself is a worry. Because Johnston is awful.