Mister Defense

What say you there? The question starts with an "if" indicating some thought is going come at the end of the sentence. It doesn't, so can you clarify what your point is here? What is the missing thought, point of that question? But yes, Tasker is almost a mess on there now that he has become so involved in promoting the Bills the last few years. Last year, he was adamant in his defense of Dorsey even as it became glaringly obvious a change was needed. Then, after that, he seemed to forget what his position was, praising the move. Maddy is good, seems to work hard at what she does, but yeah, a homer. Chris Brown is more objective, seems a little less focused on always trying to put the Bills in the best light.

To see that, so many touchdowns, and such incredible balance (hence, Josh has his best year, duh) combined with the most points scored in the league, 612!, should sharpen their focus like a laser on now getting the best 3-4 defensive players they can in the draft. They should take their ten picks and make them 4 better picks instead, moving up strategically to get the kind of defensive players needed to immediately improve the defense. Kansas City did it in one draft and so did the Eagles. They both won Super Bowls the following year. The Eagles were ranked 30th in defense in 2023. In 2024, they were the best defense in the league. By far the best defense. By almost 40 yards per game. Where there's a will there's a way.

Yup, and the Bills could do more of the same, though they do that pretty well overall. Makes sense, if done wisely, because the cap seems to be exploding anyway. So makes it less risky, less likely the bottom will fall out down the road.

Great. Thanks. Only wish that Coleman gave Josh a little more time to say something directly to the troops. These two better be spending an inordinate amount of time together this off season, practicing as much as possible, and hopefully with at least 1-2 of the other wideouts when possible. And I don't mean 1-2 weeks.. Because if Coleman has the kind of year it looked like he was going to have before the injury, the league should be on notice.

Your OP loses all credibility with that statement, now in bold above. KIncaid has never made a "tough" catch!! But I assume that this was just posted in the heat of the moment, after the very depressing loss.

Why do you have the 2025 offensive expenditures here, a season yet to be played, and one in which we do not know what the actual $ spent or outcome will be? Without the numbers for 2024 doesn't it make the last question you ask in your OP irrelevant? And the other questions too would be much better served with the 2024 numbers--folks will be focused much more on what the last season revealed, than one that has not yet been played. Can you clarify this, give the actual 2024 money spent and add a new post in the thread maybe? As I looked online and could not find it exactly. But I did find the offensive offensive expenditure for the Bills' offense at the same time last year. In March of last year, the Bills ranked 20th in the league at $116 million for 2024 offensive salaries. Of course, I do not know what the final figure was. An excellent idea for an OP, but the 2024 offensive salaries will make things much clearer, and make it all more relevant.

Actually the Bills were the highest scoring offense last year, in the regular season and playoffs combined. That is what the poster was referring to. The Bills were #1 in the league, with the Eagles 2nd at 608. The Bills scored 612 points. Hard to believe that number when I saw it--over 600 points!

Well, I do not think the Bills had the "best everything" last year, as they had a paper tiger of a defense, poor at stopping 3rd down conversions, and at giving up big plays, and not good at stopping the run. I was not happy with this, but figured they would muddle through until next year, with the high level offense rising to the occasion. (I always want my team to have a great defense. When I was born my mom took one look at my mug, saw this in my eyes, and hence my name.) They were a team that was at the very least in a big tweak year, if not a mini rebuild. But they made it to the AFC Championship game, and were leading the two time defending Super Bowl champions in their own house, late in the 4th quarter. They did that with a defense that was not high level, clearly in need of major changes in the secondary and defensive line, something Beane and McDermott are well aware of. And with those clear and obvious defensive problems, they were a whisper away from winning the game and heading to the Super Bowl--without their best CB, one of the top corners in the game, and without their best starting safety. Those were tremendous obstacles, as they were playing against the three time SB champions and two time MVP, someone most already consider to be one of the top 2-3 quarterbacks in league history. It is a game, and sometimes the ball doesn't bounce the right way. But with this Bills team, with a better defense next year, and an offense on the cusp of greatness, it is hard for me to imagine them not being the team to beat in the AFC.

I think almost everyone who watched this kick a*s offense last year would agree that adding a fast wideout who could get down field and separate would take it to another level. Once they get that, in my view, they may become the best offense ever. Without it though, they still may become that this year, but less likely.

Shoot, after reading this post I wonder what would happen if the Bills had good talent on offense... Would they be better than the 2nd best scoring offense in the NFL, as they were last year? Or better than one of the best points per drive in NFL history? Maybe then the Bills would be able to beat the elite teams, at least on occasion, like the Ravens, Lions, Chiefs...? I would love to have that happen, just on occasion, as they always come up short when they do play the better, elite teams. Maybe next year Beane will get some talent on offense that can beat a high level team, or two, score a slew of points, and challenge for a championship. But looking at last year, and his history, who would ever be that naive?

That last question is flat out stupid, at least from what it appears to imply. Why put that there? If anything, it is clear they are getting great value. And why not give us the 2024 $ allocated instead, as that is what the post seems to be about, right? We have no idea what will happen in 2025 on offense. In 2024, they scored 525 points, second in the league, almost 31 points a game. They had one of the best offenses ever in the NFL in 2024 and it looks like it will be even better in 2025. Brady's second year as OC, and a better wideout room, with more experience and better talent. IMO. If the 2024 number is the same, we don't have it in the post for some reason, then it appears Beane is responsible for a tremendous bargain.

Best coach since Marv, and one of the top coaches over the last decade in the NFL. Loaded with integrity. Happy Birthday, McD!

You say "rape is worse than murder". I think most would disagree with that statement, almost all, actually. I cannot imagine anyone in this country, if they had to choose one of those horrendous options for someone they loved, choosing that they be murdered instead. I have thought about this previously and believe that type of societal mindset may be, for some who rape, the reason they then kill their victim. Yes, rape is a horrible crime but to end the existence of someone is a dramatically more heinous crime.

? I did know that Wiley had serious character issues. It has been a long time since he played and cannot think of any examples to back that up. What are those? As that may cause me and others to change our perspective.

The Bills were missing their starting safety at the outset, and early in the first quarter they lost their best cornerback, one of the best in the league. Two vital players gone on defense, as they played against the two time MVP QB. Yet they still were beating the chiefs, at their home, late in the first quarter in the championship game. It further exposed the Bills' weaknesses on defense, their lack of high end players in the secondary and their need of a revamped D-Line. Something we had seen for almost the entire year. It was more evidence to me that the Bills need to get those areas fixed, and not with 'okay band aids', but with as high level players as possible. And it also showed the need for a wideout who could get open consistently down the field, to help them take the next step on offense. It should be pretty clear by the start of the season, or by Halloween?, if the Bills have taken the steps needed to win the next one--and to get that game at home next year.

Well, looking at PFF he made improvements last year in most aspects of his game. Pretty good upside according to the pre draft info. Huge. 26 years old. Hey, you never know. Jerry Hughes had not done much before the Bills got him at roughly the same age. Hughes had 5 sacks in his first 3 years at Indi--and then 20 in his first two years in Buffalo. At 6' 5" and 335 pounds, with good speed, maybe the new defensive line coach can move him forward. Hughes became one of the best pass rushers the Bills have had. Maybe Fotu can become a force in the middle, or at least a good rotational player against the run. I like the fact that he is young, and not a barnacle.

Stephon Gilmore, in my view. Homecoming. Older than Douglas but seemed to play much better than him this year. A few years older, but likely a future Hall of Famer. They need someone, as the cupboard is strikingly bare at cornerback, almost embarrassingly so for Beane.

THIRTY years later, 30, and they were adults at the time. Accusations like this make no sense. There is almost no fair way to now evaluate the veracity of this story, THIRTY years later. Extremely unfair to Wiley, as he is now stained for life.

So sad, but why not take the next step and make another awful move if you are the Browns? The Dog Pound, in winter, sitting in a big cozy warm living room will no longer have much bark. Tailgating will diminish substantially, as it has been reported to do when other teams move their team inside a giant warm living room: who wants to get ready for the game out in the elements, when you can just pull up in your warm car, and then head into your warm, cozy stadium. Fits soo well with a team that now lacks an identity, direction, and focus on what has made the Cleveland Browns who they are. Are the same yahoos who thought giving Watson a king's ransom to play quarterback, two years removed from the game and his life rocked by his salacious behavior behind this move? (Yes, I am not a fan of domes! Went to some football games at the SU Carrier dome during college and felt like I was sitting in giant, warm living room. Horrible atmosphere. To me, so bad it was almost no longer football.)

Obviously an area I disagree with you is the wide receivers. For reasons we still do not know completely of course, Cooper was a difference maker in only a few games, and so was not the player the Bill envisioned. 297 yards with the Bills. And I thought Hollins would have his best year as a pro here, but was not close, though he did play an important role and came on more as the year progressed. 378 yards for the Bills, while I thought he may eclipse the 690 yards with the Raiders just two seasons ago. It seems pretty clear that the Bills are determined to not make the same (possible) mistake they made with Samuels and fully believe that Joshua Palmer will be a starter next year, and a good one, With his route running and separation ability, I think he will be that this year, opening an area of the field that was too often neglected last year and which made it easier to defend an otherwise high level offense. I see Palmer as a 1000 yard receiver, far surpassing the productivity of Cooper and Hollins last season, and making an already excellent offense even better. Maybe wishful thinking. We'll see. And, yes, I also figured in Bishop's expected progress at safety as one of my reasons for improved safety play next year. The new found talent with Forrest, and the depth with Hamlin, likely mean a return, somewhat, to the high level safety play the Bills have been known for since McDermott took over, improving the very poor 3rd down efficiency and stopping many of the big plays. And while still in need of help, a huge D-tackle (or two) and an end, the D-line is improved with the three additions. Right now the cornerbacks may be the weakest the Bills have had in a long time, well before McDermott, but Douglas seemed to hit a wall last year. I don't want him back unless they are desperate, which they may be. They better get a decent cornerback before the draft somehow, or they will likely need 3 good ones there, which is tough to accomplish. The combo of some of these things makes me more hopeful than you are that the moves so far, and what is to come, are just what the Bills may need to take the next step. So I find these moves making me 'really hopeful' that they are doing the things to take the next step next year, as opposed to finding them 'really disappointing'. And they have ten picks in the draft, which I believe they will now parlay into 4 higher level players. The season will reveal how well we did in our analysis, but I think the Bills are at least slightly better in several key areas. With much more to come in the draft.

Cooper's production very likely was hampered by his injury, which one doctor said was so serious he should not play again last year. We won't know this until we see Cooper play again next year, wherever that may be, or if at all. I don't think he was a bust, and that even in his limited roll he helped the Bills win a few games that they otherwise may not have won. 1250 yards, with Watson and Flacco throwing to him in Cleveland in 2023. Hard to imagine he fell off the cliff that quickly, but we'll see..

Yes, as Palmer will likely be a full time starter this year IMO. Cooper was not effective consistently, likely because of his late arrival and then a serious injury. 297 yards with the Bills. Hollins was good, especially as he got going, but only had 378 yards So, I definitely think Josh Palmer is a more vital part of this team this year than that combo last year. I firmly believe he gets much more than the combined 675 yards Hollins and Cooper got for the Bills last year. I think Palmer surpasses 1,000 yards this season and joins Shakir as the two leading receivers on the Bills. Maybe wishful thinking, best case scenario, but watch some more of his tape from the last two years. He is a starting caliber wide receiver, and a good one. Best move by Beane so far this off season, signing a missing link.

If the Bills think Cooper's injury and late arrival were the reasons he did not have a lot of productivity last year, then I want him back. He kicked kiester for a Cleveland team just two seasons ago, with 1250 yards. But if they think Cooper has hit a wall, then obviously, NO. I would hate to see Cooper go to the Patriots or Dolphins or Chiefs, or another AFC team, and have a high level year, when the Bills need a player like Cooper was in 2023, a guy that can put them over the top if that is the case. Glad there is little interest, so hoping he signs for a low number, under 10, but with good incentives. It would ease many minds as far as the WR room is concerned, and may give the Bills more draft capital to parlay their 10 picks into the 3-4 best D-tackles/cornerbacks they can move up to get. He likes it in Buffalo, and may want to end his career with a team he feels comfortable with, that he enjoys playing with, and that gives him the best hope of ending his career with a championship.

Who said they remain the same? You say it, and few others, who bash almost every move the Bills make, always. Better at wide receiver with Palmer, a guy who averaged 15 yards a catch the last two years, runs great routes, and gets open in the intermediate+ area of the field. Better at safety with Forrest who may become a starter, and the resigning of Hamlin, adding some depth and a safety net. Better on the D-lIne with Bosa, Hoecht, and Ogunjobi, though the suspensions hurt. Three areas in need of help, improved, by most objective standards that is... Hard to imagine anyone saying that the Bills have not gotten better in the off season. For a team that was in the AFC Championship game and leading late in the 4th quarter. And now a draft with a solid amount of capital to get a high quality D-tackle, some good CBs, and a speedy wideout.

Without the two suspensions may have said I was very satisfied. But the Bills did get stronger I think. Better at wide receiver with a likely starter in Palmer. Someone who runs good routes, gets separation, and can get down the field, with over 15 yards per catch the last two seasons. The offense was hungry for a player like that last year, to open up that part of the field consistently. I hope no one offers Amari Cooper much and he plays for under ten million, with incentives. The wide receivers would be set, much improved. Better on the defensive line, with players who will play a lot of snaps this year, stopping the run much more effectively and getting more pressure on passers. Better in the secondary, with the addition of Darrick Forest and resigning of Damar Hamlin. If Bishop comes through the Bills safety play will be much improved this year. Now they can focus like a laser on 2 defensive tackles and 3 cornerbacks. 1 wideout.