MarlinTheMagician

I think this is a distinct possibility, but I think it is coin flip. Thus my concern. As other posters stated, he was undeniably tentative, at least in the first half of the year. Could be he didn't trust what he did see and didn't see enough - rookie problem that will clear. There was some improvement in the second half, but I did not see it as dramatic. I think he has a lot to prove this year to justify his draft status - he will either emerge or fade. He definitely does not seem to have the quicks to be a plus FS. I think his path is SS and to capture that opportunity he is going to have to assert himself more physically. Certainly could happen, but he has not proven it yet or showed enough flashes that I feel comfortable. Utah is over. Don't care about any insults, he is a big variable in the D - if he is a plus NFL starter our D looks a lot better than if he can't break into the lineup. Given apparent coverage limitations he needs to do that with physicality.

Take Spender Brown - clean cut, but a real bastard from day one. Wanted to put defenders though the turf. Was always obvious. Same for our extra-lineman dude whose name I forget at the moment. Mean.

Kind of like it. Guarantees a level playing field and rewards ingenuity.

Bless you. Hang out with Cole some this summer. Corrupt him.

Don't think you will get that. Hell, if not one other poster is worried at all about Bishop's development, I guess that does make me feel better. BUT - there is no way the top two safeties would have been mocked to us so often, or that persons on this board would have clamored for one of them, if Cole had balled out last year. The concern was not that "he didn't play well" - I thought he kind of played okay-ish. The concern was I did not see plays that demonstrated the traits we drafted him for -- size and speed used to deliver authoritative hits. Take Josh, or Shakir or Spencer Brown - they all did that even when experiencing rookie struggles. Not trashing the young man, not even saying he didn't play decent for a rook, but show me a little more sandpaper.

When someone says "kidding" it is usually a tell!

I do feel reassured by the first paragraph - and heck, I even know that is absolutely a truism, can't judge a book by its cover. But I really want to see it. I would rather he miss badly, but aggressively, than settle for "scheme sound." Not saying he will settle for that, but I want to see it. Match my SAT score bro, dare you! Kidding, but I very much want to be stupid here. I want to see him square some folks up. If you can honestly say you saw a lot of that last year, I was not watching the same performance. It is time. I hope it happens.

Agree with the second part, but you have to admit Tasker looked like a choirboy in a kind of psychopathic way -- still does. Like Lenny Dykstra (who looked innocent when very young). Plus, my man Tasker played with unbridled aggression from the first play I ever saw of his. Dude was just a baller, and I am sincerely hopeful that is in Cole. I want to see it. In the NFL. Let's go Cole! I think he is a key for the D - a fact that is noted, but I think underrated.

Yeah, is similar to the bad feeling I had about Josh Rosen, only different. Looking at the pictures and interviews of that pencil-necked tool, all I could think was "never, ever will be a leader of strong men, and therefore will fail as an NFL QB." So ffs me all you want, I have a track record 😀 And like I said, would love to be wrong. Rapp - he is a train wreck the way he injures everyone and can't say healthy himself, but just looking at him you can picture him putting a hurt on people. That is great - and I read the same kinds of reviews when he was drafted. The play I saw last year was more tentative, in my eyes. Could just be because he was a rook and missed time, but I hope what you saw at Utah translates to the NFL - it doesn't always. If it does, and I am 100% rooting for him, my next worry will be "can he stay healthy".

I feel a need to be reassured by the board. I get a creeping fear - which can only be based on some weird, deep-seated prejudice -- that Cole Bishop may well lack the toughness to be an NFL strong safety. Maybe he looks a little bit too much like a choirboy. Maybe he is too handsome and I am secretly jealous. I am 100% rooting for him. I know he has the height, weight and speed. But I look at him and think "likely to be scheme sound." No, please! I want to look at him and say "geez, I would sure hate to be a running back and see that animal flying downhill at me. Snot flying, drool dripping, that dude is going to wreck someone." I want to think - wide receiver over the middle? Not worried about it, Bishop will get there and lay the MoFo out. They may complete one, but it will be VERY expensive for them. Tell me I am stupid, a hater or just off base. I really liked the pick when they made it, I am hoping he grows into a silent assassin on the back-end. Even if he is scheme sound too (and I know he wasn't always that last year either). Let's go Cole - cheering for you, and want to feel stupid for doubting you. I may have to buy a Bishop jersey just to exorcise my doubts. Thoughts?

And "we need another receiver"

You heard it here first - save the post - he plays all 17 this year.

Raiders at Bills, 1967. Dad took me to my first game. Sure miss that guy. Was at The Rockpile, of course. A framed picture of a Bills interception that day sits in a privileged bookshelf position in my NYC office. Will always be my favorite Bills game, even if they win the Super Bowl. Thanks Dad.

No, no, no - don't jinx it folks!

Not high, pregnant. Those butterflies --

Yeah, F the Chiefs. Mahomes is on the downside of his career 😃 (a man can dream - he has taken a bit of a beating lately). But agree, kidding aside, we have to run our own race. And despite the recent past, I like our guy better than their guy.

Not a believer in Moore, really would have liked Keenan Allen. I trust Beane and can't believe he would bring Moore in just to appease the critics. So I will put my negativity aside and turn to my love of our team. I hope Moore proves me wrong and kills it. Let's go Elijah (gulp)! Behave yourself!!

Instead, eject him forcibly.

Also benched by Cleveland for "disciplinary reasons" Stefanski was classy enough to "keep internal" and has his Daddy crying for him over targets on social media. No thanks. As if things are not bad enough for the Cleveland Browns, fans had a horrible deja-vu moment when wide receiver Elijah Moore's father complained about his son's lack of targets on social media. Moore's father expressed disgust with his son's single target during the Week 4 loss to the Las Vegas Raiders.

You're right, Moore is an absolute a**hole and Hamler is not. I remember this guy vividly with the Jets and I REALLY don't want him. Contemporary news report: Shortly before Elijah Moore requested a trade from the Jets in October, the receiver was sent home from practice after reportedly voicing his frustrationand displeasure with his role in New York's offense. Moore wasn't getting the ball, producing numbers that paled in comparison to his promising performance as a rookie in 2021. Three months later, more details have emerged from that outburst that took place behind closed doors, a situation that involved a confrontation with former offensive coordinator Mike LaFleur. According to Zack Rosenblatt of The Athletic, Moore told LaFleur to "go f— yourself" in practice after he was held without a catch in a win over the Packers in Week 6. Here's more from Rosenblatt on the heated exchange: His frustration spilled into practice that week. That Thursday, Moore surprised teammates and coaches by blowing up on LaFleur, telling him to “go f— yourself” and “you suck,” according to multiple people who witnessed the interaction. LaFleur and Saleh ultimately decided to send Moore home to cool off. That night, he requested a trade.

Agree with everything except "he's better than Shavers." I don't necessarily disagree with that either, but what do we base that on? Shavers has been in the lab working on his body and the offense for two years. How do we know how good he is at this point? We do well developing OL on the PS - if we don't think Shavers (or Hamlin, or Virgil) can ever be promoted, we need to get different guys on the PS that have traits suggesting they could come up and win a job at some point if they develop. Same with Shavers. If we need a fast little guy we already have one in Hamler. Not sure we need that - Shavers brings something different. They clearly like Virgil too. The only FA WRs I would want are Allen or maybe Cooper if the Bills think injury hurt his performance.

I don't know. Seems like JAG to me - speedy little guy with a potentially bad attitude. He was picked slightly higher than Hamler, but they are pretty similar -- they are both very fast slots, and, admittedly, Moore is somewhat more accomplished in college (and meaningfully more in the pros). But the league valued them closely not long ago, and Hamler has put his ego on the shelf and put in two years of work to earn his way on to our team. Personally, if we feel compelled to dumpster dive for a WR, I would rather have Keenan Allen, forget the fantasy of 4.35 speed (for now), and move the chains with a proven pro like Allen. See below: Moore’s second-round draft capital (34th overall to the Jets) reflected stronger consensus compared to Hamler’s late-second-round selection (46th overall to Denver), with scouts citing Moore’s polish and YAC ability as translatable NFL traits. Both profiled as slot-dependent receivers, but Moore’s college production against SEC competition and technical proficiency made him the safer projection. Elijah Moore's Reputation Recent reports suggest attitude concerns have emerged. During the 2024 season, the Browns benched Moore early in a game against the Bengals for disciplinary reasons, though specifics were undisclosed. Additionally, Reddit discussions speculate about a potential locker-room issue, with one commenter alleging a combination of "lack of skill" and "negative influence" as factors in his unsigned free-agent status.

We got two perimeter corners, Hairston and a back-up (Strong). Both great picks, IMHO. Beane already said Hancock will play safety and back-up the slot. Both of those are big time needs. So love that pick too. When Rapp leaves, Bishop is more of a strong safety. Hancock more of a free. When Tre White and Dane Jackson leave, it is Benford, Hairston, and Strong as our primary back-up. That is definitely not excessive. This all seems like excellent team building for now and the future to me.

But maybe think of it as two corners and one safety that can back up the slot. Seems very reasonable - safety and two corners. The cupboard was very bare.

This makes sense to me. Dane will be one of the friendly vet PS players maybe.