We didn't play Atlanta last year, it was 2017. In that year we had 11 games with under 200 yards passing per game and 2 under 100.
You said "completely unreliable". That's not true and you just described how it isn't. I didn't say he was reliable.
I'm saying on a team that was in 2015 the 28th lowest passing team, in 2016 the 30th passing team and in 2017 the 31st passing team - he produced. He was 20%, 19% and 24% of the passing offense on average in 2015-2017. He ranked no lower than 3rd on the team in yards and catches in those years. He was 1st in catches or yards twice.
We were a putrid passing offense during his time here. He wasn't a total bust.