NastyNateSoldiers

Most of our best players was pkd up in 2017 bud, Hyde, Poyer, Milano, Dawkins, & Tre all from 2017 class which Beane has no connection to.

Yes it does it proves he doesn’t know value which he absolutely doesn’t have a feel for the draft it’s strengths it’s weaknesses. He’s drafted a bunch of jags especially in first 3 rds . Even the yr he traded for Diggs he didn’t have a feel for that strong class of Wrs. The proof is in the pudding and thank God he did hit on Allen next him and McD are living off that creature success.

Brandon Beane is a mediocre GM . I said it I don’t care how many games Allen carry’s this franchise on his bk . Beane has sucked in free agency and draft he sucks! Plain and simple . If either of us sucked at our jobs as much as him we’d be fired.

Edmunds trade up did suck ! I wanted Leonard and Warner later believe me I’m a draft geek! Those 2 players u could’ve traded bk and got 1 off them load up on pks instead of unload.

He’s horrible at trading up also . See Cody Ford for proof, 😂.

This is true BUT! It was a different front office and scouts that makes a huge difference. Do u think Mcd scouted Tre White? I highly doubt it. U got to give 2017 draft credit to Mcd, Whaley and the rest of his front office and u know what other then Joshie that’s been by far the best draft of the Mcd era and I wish we would’ve kept Whaley and his staff on they were a lot better then Beane and his buddies at drafting they ran circles around them.

Beaner doesn’t know how to draft in early rds it’s so weird! 😂 It’s all Allen ! Without Allen this is a 4 win team.

I’m not sure 1 particular thing can be done to get the Bills to the Super Bowl this team is flawed in many ways. Your list is pretty much spot on and I would have to say nearly everything on that list is almost as important as the other. I voted for Oline that’s the one that stands out to me but we also need an identity as a team a physical identity which we don’t have we’re not a big strong team and we’re not a fast team. We really have no physical identity or even an aggressive mentality. I really believe those 2 things are paramount to winning the Super Bowl. If u look at all the past Super Bowl winners especially in the last 10yrs u would see exactly what I’m saying. 2022 - Chiefs 2021- Rams 2020- Bucs 2019 - Chiefs 2018- Pats 2017- Eagles 2016- Pats 2015- Broncos 2014- Pats 2013- Seahawks All these teams had Physical identities they had great front 7s on defense and played aggressive styles only 1 team on this list played Zone defense and that was the Seahawks but they also played a ton of man to man especially in the Super Bowl vs the Broncos and the Seahawks were nasty physical team . Most of the other defenses on this list were more hybrid defenses and they played more man to man . The Chiefs defense is an aggressive unit they might not be very talented like the rest on this list but they make up for it with there versatile schemes and aggression. I can go on and on with the differences with these winners but the most thing that stands out is we’re not anywhere near being a Super Bowl caliber defense because we’re anti aggressive in our scheme we play reactionary ball and we’re not physically gifted either. On Offense other then Josh we’re not physically gifted we’re not fast we’re not physical we’re more finesse but without the speed . Our running scheme is more zone then anything else and those little backs ain’t wearing any defense down . We might have the mentality when it comes to offense but most of that is from Josh. The Oline is not a Super Bowl caliber unit at all . It’s basically the Josh show and nothing else there’s no scheming that gets Wrs open no easy plays every team on that list knew how to run a screen and they all got there RBs involved in the passing game. At the end of the day we are not SUPERBOWL CALIBER! on nearly any level that corresponds to the teams that have won. We don’t have the aggressive mentality on offense or defense and we definitely don’t have the schemes or even the talent those other teams had. McBeane got a ton of work to do and they haven’t adjusted there games in any fashion over the years. I don’t think they have what it takes to direct a team to the finish line I believe they built a culture and got Josh but other then that they’ve been borderline horrible in the draft and free agency and they don’t have the mentality it takes to build a Champion!

It might happen even with Edmunds on the field.

When is this organization gonna learn that injury prone players don’t get less injury prone with age? This would be awful signing but I won’t be shocked if they do this because McBeane loves old injury prone players. Any connection to Julio might as well!

McD is loyal to a fault . He should be loyal to winning that’s what the best coaches do. Being loyal to winning is being loyal to the Fan base and organization.

I think the Bills will spend some money and a 2 picks in the draft on Oline . Sort of like the route KC took a few yrs back.

Why would u hurt your TV if the Bills are getting an outstanding talent at pick #27? The Bills need stars and if Gibbs fits the Bill as one then that’s a home run pick. Actually I think he wants to see us win the Bills desperately need to fix the Oline and add a do it all weapon at RB . Cook is a nice player but he ain’t that he’s a scat back or 3rd down back. If Gibbs ends up like Kamara do u complain then?

And since this is fun I’m gonna say ODB tears his ACL on Thanksgiving day! 😂

To be honest not sure about the pass catchers being better we got never Wrs by a mile and they have the better TEs. Cook can catch out the backfield just as well as McKinnon. There Oline and backs are better there QB is better and last but not least there coaches are on another planet. I truly believe the coaching is the biggest difference.

It’s like going to a bakery and ordering the vanilla cake every time there’s no toppings no fruits no nothing on that cake just plain vanilla. 😂

I don’t think the Bills know anything about the Bills we have no identity. This Pk wouldn’t surprise me either . Every time i see someone say resign Singletary I cringe a little. 😂

I wonder where Khalil Shakir would be ranked in this draft for me it’s #4 behind Johnston, Addison & Flowers . Shakir and JSN seem like the same type of player . I would think about Johnston at #27 but Addison and Flowers would have to be at our Pk in the 2nd rd. Those guys are too small to be first rd pks.

Enough red flags to build a courthouse! Johnston I’d look as at #27 but everyone else in 3rd rd.

We’ll see if Austin is just a gimmick guy he was injured this whole season. This kid can run a routes and is excellent after the catch and his speed $ quickness shows on film.

I don’t even know if I would put Addison with these guys. I loved Calvin Austin lll last yr he didn’t play for the Steelers but I believe he’s the reason they traded away Claypool.

I agree and disagree. I agree we need a future #1 Wr I disagree that Wr is available in this draft. This class of Wrs is brutally bad in my opinion and we should draft to rebuild the Oline with a much better class of prospects at that position. Kick the can to 2024 draft for that Wr we’re there’s much better players. Beane has to be careful no more blowing picks he needs to know where the strength is in the draft and follow suit because u blow this Pk your in a awkward position going into the next draft where now u can’t take a WR again . It’s kind of like the dog chasing his tail analogy .

Veach playing chess and Beane playing checkers ! Btw the Bills interviewed Veach for GM job I wish we would’ve hired him.

Yes we need a Wr but the Oline and elite RB way more important.

Kind of puts a lock on the Bills loving them some has been over the hill players.