Fat Bob's was one of the worst places ive ever been too. Is the only place i didnt take the leftovers home.
I live in the southern tier as well and Mama's Smokin BBQ in Shongo is great. The things they smoke are awesome but regular food not so much. If want a burger dont go but if you want a smoked brisket Philly then come on over. They burned down last fall but they are rebuilding as we speak , can't wait !
Across the street from them is a dive bar called Just One More is surprisingly pretty good also. They make a killer Philly as well, just not a BBQ place.
https://m.facebook.com/Mamas-Smokin-BBQ-1676317872595865/
Ive heard this place in Hinsdale is good but ive never been.
https://www.jdssmokingrillnbar.com