NeverOutNick

I like the energy he brings to the team but I agree talent and production trumps attitude. We have Josh Allen and 8 years of the same coaching regime in place. If Hollins is one of the best 6 then he should stay if he’s not then don’t cut a guy like Hamler or claypool over him. But saying all that he does so many of the little things right I’m sure he makes it even if it is as the 5th WR playing special teams

Yes

Love the depth at a lot of positions but a Rapp/Hamlin safety tandem is a problem. Two guys with no sense of coverage. They fly all over trying to make the big hit every play. Don’t like it

Agreed he couldn’t have said it better. Josh is the best

Secret weapon baby 🥳 man I hope he finally is healthy and plays to his potential with us

I hope you’re wrong. You’ve got 2 potential studs still under 26 in Claypool and Hamler who if they hit could be every down WRs on our team or most teams in the NFL. They’ve got that kind of talent. MVS is almost 30 years old and a one trick pony. If he was great at that one trick I’d fall in line with a lot of the posts supporting him here BUT he’s a liability with how many drops he’s had. I really hope this is a fair evaluation and best man wins.

- His contract is nothing, 1 yr / $2,250,000 - 7 post season games with the chiefs, 15 rec for 250 yard (36yds/game) 🤷🏻‍♂️ - This can be done by Claypool or Hamler as stated before. I don’t think a one trick pony is a lock and I hope the bills FO and coaching staff feels the same way especially when he drops so many wide open passes. At least when Gabe Davis did it he would give his all blocking the next play and I’m not a Davis fan in the slightest. We’ll wait and see though maybe I’m overhyping what I think Hamler is and what claypool can be

What has he done to make you or anyone else think he’s a lock? If it’s truly an open competition and he’s on the team because he can take the top off the defense, then we’re still in wait and see mode because so can Hamler and Claypool. As of right now he is far from a lock in my eyes. Samuel, Shakir and Coleman are the only locks at WR. But it sure does feel like Hollins is a locker room guy the coaching staff won’t let wall. If all that is true then preseason has a lot to say about the last 2 WR spots. I’m hoping Mr. Drop doesn’t take one of those spots but if he earns it so be it

That’s a fair point that really it’s a three-way competition between MVS, Claypool and maybe Hamler. I just hope it’s one of the latter since their hands aren’t garbage. It’ll be interesting to see how they all perform in preseason.

He has eyes, heck ya MVS is out at this point. Drops should matter Excited to see how Shavers and Hamler play this week

Any other staff and I’d say it’s a certainty MVS isn’t making it with the rise of Shavers but I don’t trust our FO to make that call. Still holding out hope that during preseason Hamler, Claypool and Shavers make it obvious that MVS is expendable because I agree the guy drops way too many catchable balls to be dependable during the season. Let’s go with young guys with a lot of upside. We already have our veteran WR in Hollins

I’ve got a soft spot for jones because I remember how incredible he once was for Atlanta so here’s hoping he’s back to that level for us

My pre draft rankings and analysis below. He could be special but he’s far from a finished product. Definitely has a lot of traits us Bills fans are excited about. Tee Higgins is a fine comparison but hopefully he develops into a better overall WR than Tee.

I really like Hamler’s upside. He’s got special speed too. Ideally he and Claypool finally live up to their potential and make our team.

Seems like Hollins is a lock at this point. Hopefully it’s a fair competition between MVS and Claypool and I’m hoping Claypool, having the more upside to be special wins. MVS is what he is. He’ll have an occasional deep catch but drops too many catchable balls to ever be reliable.

I hope I’m wrong on Drake Maye. I know he went to the worst possible situation, but the kid is the best QB in this draft class and I hate that he’s in our division.

You can honestly say that Daboll, McDaniel and Pederson wouldn’t elevate Josh and the offensive to new heights? again it’s just my opinion but I’ve seen enough of what McD can’t do to know he’s not a top 10 coach. And all of the guys I listed would do better with the team we have.

100% He may be a good man and a great leader but his in game decision making is pitiful and costs us a few games each year, especially when it matters most. I can not overlook how he directly screws our chances at getting to the Super Bowl year in and year out come playoff time by his incompetence or lack of preparation and adjustment while Josh is putting the whole team on his back, playing out of his mind. I know under McD we will be steady and get our 10-12 wins each year but he’s not Lafleur or Andy Reid that are so gifted with offensive minds that he can elevate his teams play in big moments and make the proper adjustments when you have a less than ideal supporting cast to work with. Hes a fine coach but I can list 15 current coaches I’d rather have coaching Josh Allen now and come playoff time that I know wouldn’t botch things up like he has: 1. Andy Reid 2. Matt Lafleur 3. Sean McVay 4. Kyle Shanahan (don’t totally trust him in big moments but he’s a great offensive mind that would elevate Josh) 5. Dan Campbell 6. Jim Harbaugh 7. Kevin Stefanski 8. Mike McDaniel 9. Kevin O’Connell 10. Brian Daboll 11. Sean Payton (hate this guy but he’s a heck of an offensive mind and decisive in big games) 12. John Harbaugh (my first non offensive mind who is as steady as they come) 13. Shane Steichen (He’s the reason eagles were such an offensive juggernaut a couple years ago and the reason the colts gave teams fits last year with Minchew at QB) 14. Doug Pederson (see Sean Payton) 15. Mike Tomlin (basically McDermott without the stupid in game decisions) honorable mentions: Demeco Ryans and Zach Taylor are both better in game managers than McD any of the top 14 outside of John would elevate Josh’s game and we’d never have to worry about our offense drastically changing because our HC would be an offensive mind. I concede that this FO and ownership love and will go down in a blaze of glory with McD but I hate it because Josh is in my opinion, the best player in the NFL and what we get from McD isn’t enough to get Josh the title he deserves

Fixed it for you

I love Eric Moulds and Andre Reed but man getting an in his prime TO would be hard to beat. TO at his best is an all time top 5 WR even with the baggage

I don’t think we’re “better”. I think we’re deeper. This is how I see it: Last year This year Diggs Shakir Davis Coleman Shakir Samuel Harty Claypool Sherfield MVS Hollins Hamler Shakir is our #1 for this year and he’s earned that role even if he’s not built like a true #1. Will Coleman be the guy eventually? Maybe. He’s a big target that snatches the ball out of the air but isn’t a great separator just yet. Samuel is not special. He’s been the #2 or 3 option on every team he’s ever been on because he’s not a great route runner or even a deep threat (surprising for a guy who is so fast). He is a fun gadget player who is a way better version of what McKenzie was supposed to be. Claypool has the most upside of any player left and seems like he’s proving it in camp. I hope he finally puts it all together and isn’t just a nice preseason story. MVS is a deep threat who drops a lot of catchable balls. I don’t think he’s a lock to make the team but he’s a big deep threat so he’s safer than most. Hollins is the special teams dude captain that McDermott loves. On most teams he wouldn’t be a lock but he probably is with our safe conservative head coach. Hamler had all world potential. He is just never healthy. If he’s finally healthy I’d leapfrog him into the top 4 discussion because of his skill set to break the top off the d and ability to score a TD any time the ball is in his hands either punt return or catching the ball from Josh. it’s a much deeper WR room than last year which is good because of injuries but it’s not “better”. Diggs, even if last year was a down year, is a true #1 type WR who has mastered route running and outside of last year was always clutch in big moments. Hopefully someone steps up to be that guy this year but I was hoping we traded up for that guy in Odunze in the draft (not bitching because I’m sure it was discussed but too expensive) I am quietly optimistic about this years WR room but I am not expecting anyone to be a true #1 target at WR. If anything I think that guy will be Kincaid

Pay him whatever he wants, whenever he wants. He’s the only reason we’re a Super Bowl contender. Lock him up as a Bill for life

He should have final word. McD doesn’t need to be involved in player evaluation, it’s not his job. He should be like most other coaches in the league and shut up and color during the actual draft since I’m sure months prior he told Beane what “he needs”

If any coach had Allen the drought would’ve been over. He is the best talent QB the league has ever seen. But I agree Chan was at least creative and would’ve been more successful than the current regime imo

I agree. Safety is fine and thank God Hamlin is probably gone. I do think Hyde would come back if needed and that gives me comfort come playoffs. He’s got a few good games left in him and would love for him to win a SB on this squad