NoSaint

the hope has to be health he moved like a cruise ship last year. Hopefully he gets a little more nimble. to be fair, there’s a hell of a lot more guys that don’t dramatically improve after 3 seasons usually you are in the ballpark of who they are, unless they simply were stuck behind someone for reps

he’s caught deep balls but is he a field stretcher? He’s not a particularly fast guy.

Yea, this is way too early to catch o line insight

I didn’t begin to imply he’s a flyer but at $5m per year he’s not paid as a WR2 either. He’s a relatively cheap and explosive question mark that could make some impact plays. He’s not a WR2. you’re digging the hole deeper with comments like this

the whole problem is that outside of like 5 guys, most are relatively replaceable it’s a common skill set and body type and backs 10 through 64 don’t change quality tooooo drastically as long as they fit your scheme.

throwing in the Isabella signing makes him look particularly oblivious to reality

honestly with a healthy Davis and healthy Josh I would find it hard to believe his targets drop in a substantial way this year

hate this take for a variety of reasons. terrible return on the asset in your suggestion the fact that you think harty flashing in non contact is meaningful just bad all around

imagine the kicking advantage we are buying with a new stadium A little side eye to this, as obviously the team was getting the board to engage fans now that the stadium experience is sagging with the team underperforming. That said, May as well make the most of it and get in visiting kickers heads

Yea- I think he’s burning through goodwill more quickly than expected with moves like that. having Brady likely got him used to being able to do a lot of unconventional things that you can’t get away with when you have a bad qb. the huge one is the wins record

he was on a jet ski though. and common sense says that if your contract gives this freedom to the team you stay away from them. Even if you are personally safe, something can happen to you easily. It’s not worth the risk, unless you are incredibly over the top passionate about it.

and would’ve been in the Super Bowl (again) if not for that PI no call vs the rams… yea, not a swipe i would take but I think a little extra color makes the soap opera we all watch more lively.

Weak joke…

he and breece are an elite 1-2 potentially but I think we all feel like an opponent paying a top tier money and drafting a guy very high is not optimizing their resources

he fits in that you need like 10 guys to run routes in the first team, second team plus a few of those guys playing special teams reps. he’s a warm body to functionally run a full practice, and anything more is free money

he’s a “we need to have 90 of them, and doesn’t hurt to have a fast guy learn the playbook in case the injury bug hits” signing. nothing wrong with that. But nothing to really celebrate either.

though plenty of others struggled. our perspectives a bit warped by how well our guys have beat him. It’s not the norm though.

can always carry over to next year. Flexibility is good for them either way.

to be fair, only Lamar is trying to be forced into the top 3 conversation amongst the two. no one thinks Herbert is ELITE, just an excellent young qb. If you use the range of is Lamar a top 5-10 guy, everyone loves him too. and after Lawrence and burrow… just wait for that Josh Allen guy to reset the market

cousins… man… you can see there are glimpses of a human somewhere in there. he’s like if you typed “suburban religious football man” into an AI app

Whoever released the verbiage was just trying to clearly offload fault to the other party

I’ll stress again, he just signed a contract to be WR8 on their depth chart. neither he nor the giants think he’s a starter it’s amazing some posters think otherwise

covid was just an opportunity for him to be a dramatic distraction. he has said numerous times social media is bad for him and he should stay off it, as an example of him being dysfunctional in that regard. it was about the approach he took, not his specific medical hot takes had it been covid only we could roll today but he is still the same human who can’t help himself in attention seeking

at age 34 it should surprise you if he puts up prime of his career performance. Him making the roster isn’t even a given. There’s an argument he’s WR8 for them going into camp. Especially after a meaningful dip 2 years ago, and not being able to find a team last year… there’s no reason to think he’s more than injury insurance

that’s not the reason at all boss… good try.