NoSaint

im not sure any of us much know. Even if you dislike his play calling

dont sleep on can’t guard Mike he was also without his HOF qb and dominated this season. The dude catches everything.

taking less and spreading it would’ve just let us roll over even more to today if we didn’t spend the freed up cash

best road record of late - saints. best bad weather teams - steelers, pats, and Green Bay all have hall of fame qbs i know the smash mouth blue collar romanticism loves big ugly unsung guys knocking off those delicate stars of the passing game... and there’s no single way to win... but overwhelmingly the path to sustained success in this league is through the QB and passing, and putting a well rounded 52 around him

4m is 2% of your cap. For a 53 man roster 2% isn’t breaking the bank If talking beane, we have held him to a pretty small window. in Carolina they did have some guys with checkered history

this I know.

Regardless they aren’t some scrub division 3 team.

I’d sometimes agree but the dude has thrown exceptionally all year and I suspect he was late but knew he could be against a guy who is not an nfl db

Iiiiii know but I’m sure we have a few that will think twice so I figured I’d mention how they really work

no one gets a comp pick as they all cut him.

If starting a franchise in the teams era, I’d certainly not be upset getting any of the names in that range... but for the coin flip, I think owning the record books and having a ring while still not being should weigh heavy in the tie break That said, it seems obvious they didn’t want to weight any era tooo heavily and I’d struggle taking Brady or manning off. So I guess the discussion is favre vs Brees?

if you roll over the money, makes little difference anyway

yea, unless mahomes falls off a cliff and/or Allen makes a jump- kc won. But both those things are very possible with young QBs

go ahead and turn in your fan card.

you don’t know the b roll ??

cant judge josh cause he’s raw, and had a bad cast can’t judge beane because of the cap situation cant judge McD because he had josh and a talent strapped roster was a major feedback loop across a large portion up until about 2 months ago when it became uncool to have questions about any with the winning record back

I can hardly imagine this thread if it was the pats, and it’s not like Baltimore has been choir boys with behavior either

I have always thought the offensive questions are fair but the answers around here go in circles a bit. Can’t judge josh, beane or McDermott over the offense for some reason. ultimately, if Josh is Russ Wilson in Newton’s body all 3 are in the hall of fame. But the discussions are a bit grating in that we can’t question anyone because he’s too raw but can’t judge them for the position they put that raw rookie in.

the pats and Steelers have made room for plenty of “personalities” and also made big splash trades. The two of them trade me a 1 and a 2 during this season to add talent.

this could be a radical take but what if they thought he was closer to ready than a lot of this board gave credit and we don’t have to evaluate him with kid gloves

they Had seen peterman play and your cool with the take that because they weren’t winning the super bowl, whatever, he’s got the job for the season?

one might argue if a guy is THAT raw there are questions about him going that high. you can quote any interview you want. they went into the season with peterman and Allen. Either they were criminally negligent or they didn’t expect him to sit the whole season from pretty early in the process.

If Allen was expected to sit out the entire season you must’ve been mighty upset about us not creating a better qb situation around him Either beane was negligent, or he didn’t agree with you on the plan that he would be sitting.

mahomes is, fairly, an exception. But the point that you don’t draft a guy top 10 expecting him to sit in the modern Nfl is one I stand by. And as much as everyone said that was Allen, he did not sit. Frankly going into the season with he, peterman and McCarron- And dealing AJ... I don’t think they tried all that hard to avoid it. It’s just not reality to get one that high and not see him play. There’s a little noise around the data, as with anything, but I’m comfortable saying it’s materially true.

see this here is over thinking it.