Mr. WEO

Well it only takes 2 or 3 voters out of 23 to get you top or top 5. The only thing one can take away from such a sample. is that Howie Roswman is the only standout as”best GM” as far as those polled are concerned

Almost all of us here were frequently labeled as having no idea what we were watching re: Edmunds by a vocal few, so.....who knows? he's at least the best paid pile hopper in the NFL.

well if the Bills are in the market for a backup that looks great in a preseason game or 2 against the guys who get waived tomorrow AND who McD is VERY comfortable with........there is a guy they can go after

Keenum could win 11 games with this roster...

oh

That's an overplayed take. 2019-2021 the NFC was pretty solid at the top: GB, NO, Tampa Bay and then LA when Stafford got there. The AFC is a 3 team Conference.

greatest signing ever!

I bet he hasn't shown up to your birthday party in a few years...

You mean Santa Clara?

Empirically? Well, I can't verify any of this. Nor can I know if you would really have a neighbor torturing dogs in his back yard over for a beer when he got out. I just don't believe any reasonable person would.

settle down. none of the bolded matters. you wouldn't have that guy anywhere near you after he got out. you certainly wouldn't invite him over. That's all.

If he was a guy you worked with or your neighbor doing that in his back yard, you wouldn't be saying it's cool to come to your office now and chat up the fellas or knocking on your door to hang out after he did his time. Hero worship is stupid. OJ was busy?

why is this POS around the facility? "Finding that spark" for this low life meant electrocuting dogs. what possessed the FO to wake up this week and say: "we should bring in Mike Vick as a guy to chat up the fellas"...? wtf

There is absolutely no chance that Josh is lighting into guys "behind closed doors". None. He's not that kind of guy--and that's OK. To be that guy you have to have some authority to do so. If you are going to point your finger in a teammates face, it better have at least 1 ring on it. Brady, Jordan, Kobe famously did this--and it worked. They absolutely made their teammates better. Hyde? Tre?...Dawkins????!! Nah. Perhaps Miller, if he's around.

Meh. Eagles were 1-5 in playoff games with him as starter. In 2017, they won 10 of their next 12 games, including the SB, with Peters's backup in his spot. In his 12 years there, the Eagles had 7 winning seasons. When he missed the season in 2012, they won 4 games. When he played half the season in. 2020, the won 4 games (1 with him starting). The Bills would have had no different history had he finished his career there. He's waiting until week 18.....

How about Chad Kelly?

11/11ths

I agree with this. He would jump at an extension. You would have to take him for a 4th--Bills have no viable backup right now.

Ok you didn't initially respond to the other poster by saying that you specifically meant Basham... "You would trade a 2nd rounder from 2 years ago at a premium position for a 7th? I'm glad you are not GM" But your position is now that it's in some circumstances actually smart for a GM to make such a trade.

If one team does it, it should not be considered by other teams? What if it is a smart move? Still wrong?

It's the topic of this thread. A 1st rounder from 3 years ago for a 7th, so.....

here we go again....