Jump to content

Kelly Roberts [1968-2006]


SDS

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 202
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Terrible, Terrible, Terrible

 

 

We all are going to react differently to this kind of event. Murder is the worst thing anyone can do. There is no need for us to turn on each other or bicker though. It diminishes the brutal reality of the circumstances and disrespects all those that have had their lives destroyed in the past 2 days. We really have no footing to proclaim how we should all feel, so long as the reality of the actions are not lost on any of us.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I disagree.

 

I believe a reaction of RIP or "Rest in Peace" is unwarranted for any person who takes a life - their own or otherwise. You cannot take a life without taking others too. Pieces of other lifes are ripped to shreds. Whole families are torn apart. This, my friends, is the last - most despicable act. Because it has NO mercy. There are no takebacks. No healing. It is the most violence that you can bring. Killing.

 

I restrained myself from the lovefest that accompanied the first suicide. Lionizing and finding meaning - "he went to meet his love" crap. Not while children and family are left to pick up the pieces and sort thru their own feelings of hurt, guilt and shame. And suicide breeds suicide. Children of parents who kill themselves, are themselves at a far greater risk. It becomes acceptable. Cool even in some strange circles.

 

And it is not acceptable. It is vile and evil. It is the different side of the same coin murder/suicide. Do you think that it is only coincidental or accidental that family of those who kill themselves are pained by guilt and remorse? It ain't. It is the purpose of the whole thing.

 

And I am glad that at least in this case (murder) we see the act for what it is. Violence against the world. Anger and violence against the family.

 

Do you suffer from pain?

 

There is a sure way out. I swear this will work. I promise it will work.

 

If you suffer from pain, admit it. Recognize it. Now go and find someone else who has pain. And make it your lifes work to take away their pain. And as you do that; as you take care of another, your pain will subside. Suicide and murder are simply attempting to lay pain on someone else. When you spend your days ruminating about laying the wood to someone else, maybe even someone who harmed you, you descend into the hell that will consume you. To get out, start by getting someone else out.

 

When you become a loving person, you cannot bring yourself to hurt. But when you are preoccupied with being a beast and hating, you become a partner to death and destruction.

 

And when you do that, you deserve our contempt. Not our regards.

 

May those who have spent their life in service, when they die, may THEY rest in peace.

774761[/snapback]

 

I don't mean this as harshly as it will sound, but I think the 'solution' you offer is steeped in ignorance of mental illness. While there is certainly value in what you say, and I think it's a very healthy option for those who are in good mental health, the gray area of psychological illness is quite vast.

 

I don't condone suicide by any means, but in my opinion there are very clear and significant differences between the two examples we're talking about.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just got back from a bar, this story came up on the news and I just had to leave when it aired. Couldn't even look.

 

Still feel absolutely disgusted with what he did, cant wrap my mind around it at all just yet.

 

If anyone finds anything out about donating some money to his children under an anonymous heading, please let me know.

 

I dont have much being a grad student, but I want to give something to them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

gray area of psychological illness is quite vast. 

 

774780[/snapback]

 

Sure we can debate the fine points of cognition and reality too. Bottom line is that this is not steeped in ignorance of mental illness. It is a prescription. And a prescription is what you give an ill man.

 

And a prescription, a solution, a path - whatever, is preferable to a response of "golly who can fathom the mind? peace be to them " In fact mental illness can and does respond to the same triggers that we respond to.

 

But your point is to say the mind is sick, so reasonble answers need not apply. Wrong. Our responce to violence and murder should be the same. We are trying to change behavior, not someones temporary mental status.

 

If I said, 'walking is good for you. people should walk more'. You wouldn't say that I must be ignorant of the whole nature of arthritic diseases. Now that would be construed as an excuse. When you can't walk - obviously we gotta do something else. But until then, it is still worth trying to walk. And to walk in spite of the difficulty is a step (ugh) in the direction of healing to an arthritic man.

 

I am sorry that a simple prescription seems to be too simple.

 

But I did not want to simply growl at the world of darkness and evil. Rather, I thought to offer a way to change behavior. Because all that I heard after the suicide of our board partner was blather that can only end in events such as todays.

 

Again - simply as possible - to those who feel pain, your reaction can be inflicting pain on others - or it can be mitigating the pain of others. Choose the latter, and that is what will free you from YOUR pain.

 

It works for the arthritic, for the lame, for the mentally ill, and for the mentally well. It will not make you mentally well. It won't cure leprosy. It won't kick your habit.

 

It will assuage your pain.

 

I promise.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sure we can debate the fine points of cognition and reality too. Bottom line is that this is not steeped in ignorance of mental illness. It is a prescription. And a prescription is what you give an ill man.

 

And a prescription, a solution, a path - whatever, is preferable to a response of "golly who can fathom the mind? peace be to them " In fact mental illness can and does respond to the same triggers that we respond to.

 

But your point is to say the mind is sick, so reasonble answers need not apply. Wrong. Our responce to violence and murder should be the same. We are trying to change behavior, not someones temporary mental status.

 

If I said, 'walking is good for you. people should walk more'. You wouldn't say that I must be ignorant of the whole nature of arthritic diseases. Now that would be construed as an excuse. When you can't walk - obviously we gotta do something else. But until then, it is still worth trying to walk. And to walk in spite of the difficulty is a step (ugh) in the direction of healing to an arthritic man.   

 

I am sorry that a simple prescription seems to be too simple.

 

But I did not want to simply growl at the world of darkness and evil. Rather, I thought to offer a way to change behavior. Because all that I heard after the suicide of our board partner was blather that can only end in events such as todays.

 

Again - simply as possible - to those who feel pain, your reaction can be inflicting pain on others - or it can be mitigating the pain of others. Choose the latter, and that is what will free you from YOUR pain.

 

It works for the arthritic, for the lame, for the mentally ill, and for the mentally well. It will not make you mentally well. It won't cure leprosy. It won't kick your habit.

 

It will assuage your pain.

 

I promise.

774790[/snapback]

 

 

Even for arthritis, there is no "simple" effective prescription in a large percentage of cases. There are numerous causes, different parts of the body that are affected, different treatment modalities, different theories on what direction to go with research, etc, etc. On top of that, arthritis is much less subjective than mental illness.

 

Pain is an indication that something is wrong. We define it individually, and what is painful for me may not be painful for you, and vice versa. It would be wonderful if in every single case we could assuage our pain simply by, as you say, recognizing its presence and then working to mitigate the pain of others, but I have seen enough to know that is not the case.

 

The problem with your prescripton is that, at least in this instance,you don't even know the diagnosis. You don't know how far the man 'walked' from the time of his wife's passing until that of his own. Correct me if I'm wrong, but you knew very little about the man at all.

 

You say the goal is not to change the mental status, but the behavior. What exactly do you think inspires behavior? Behavior is not typically a random event. There are reasons for it, and those reasons are often times very complex. A proper prescription requires first understanding the problem. And when it comes to problems of a psychological nature, the field is fifty parts theory to one part fact. And that's probably being generous.

 

We can just agree to disagree, my friend.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess we can be thankful, for as thankless a situation that this is, that he didn't spiral down even deeper and attempt to take some police officers with him in the woods.

774399[/snapback]

 

That was a wonderful thing to say Scott.

 

We can also be thankful (again, in a thankless situation) that he took the baby to his mothers' house. I have seen these situations get worse than this one, if you can imagine.

 

I pray that the babies can recover from this trauma.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is just absolutely terrible.

What he did was a horrendous act & in no way should be excused or condoned.

However, I think we can be certain that he did not wake up that day thinking "I think I'll kill my wife & myself today."

If any good can come from this, it is perhaps a reminder to all that anger can be as insidious as addictive drugs.

To all those who perhaps let anger get the better of them on occasion(myself included), just remember to walk away before it is all too late. If you can see that you have a problem....be a man....admit it & get some help. The potential consequences are just too great not to. :pirate:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did not know T80, but I certainly knew his online persona. This is a terrible tragedy for the family--the wife, their children, and all those who love them. If there is anyone here who is close to the family, it would be appropriate to contact SDS and set up a donation fund for the children. I would contribute.

 

What strikes me about all of this is how divorced from reality on-line communication is. We pretend to have communities and friends on-line, but we are deluding ourselves. If this were a real community, and all of us real acquaintances, this would have been less likely to happen. Real communities spend face-to-face time with one another, and support one another when there is trouble, or signs of trouble.

 

We are facing a brave new world of communities where people put their happy face on when posting, but are lonely, depressed, angry, or suicidal at their home.

 

God help us all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I restrained myself from the lovefest that accompanied the first suicide. Lionizing and finding meaning - "he went to meet his love" crap. Not while children and family are left to pick up the pieces and sort thru their own feelings of hurt, guilt and shame. And suicide breeds suicide. Children of parents who kill themselves, are themselves at a far greater risk. It becomes acceptable. Cool even in some strange circles.

 

774761[/snapback]

 

Don't bring Paul (Bib) into this. You have no idea what family he had, what contact he had with them, his life story, etc.... There is no need to rehash that event with the announcement of this one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't bring Paul (Bib) into this. You have no idea what family he had, what contact he had with them, his life story, etc....  There is no need to rehash that event with the announcement of this one.

774841[/snapback]

 

 

Excuse me for my ignorance. What is this previous tragedy to which people are referring?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did not know T80, but I certainly knew his online persona.  This is a terrible tragedy for the family--the wife, their children, and all those who love them.  If there is anyone here who is close to the family, it would be appropriate to contact SDS and set up a donation fund for the children.  I would contribute.

 

What strikes me about all of this is how divorced from reality on-line communication is.  We pretend to have communities and friends on-line, but we are deluding ourselves.  If this were a real community, and all of us real acquaintances, this would have been less likely to happen.  Real communities spend face-to-face time with one another, and support one another when there is trouble, or signs of trouble. 

 

We are facing a brave new world of communities where people put their happy face on when posting, but are lonely, depressed, angry, or suicidal at their home.

 

God help us all.

774840[/snapback]

Very interesting take. I like to post on various boards on various subjects; yet at the same time, I have very little off-line interaction with any of the posters for the very reasons you cite: you just don't know who's really out there. Much easier & 'safer' to stick with friends who you know from previous face-to-face meetings, IMO anyways.

 

That being said: by taking that stance, it's a lot easier for me to seperate real life (off-line) from non-real life (on-line). That is why I absolutely abhor what T80 did in RL but will maybe even more-so miss him in non-RL. :pirate:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...