Field position and points: Keep Bass, Hauschka, Edwards and Bojorquez on the 53

[JoPoy88]

6 minutes ago, IgotBILLStopay said:

everyone, esp. the OP recognizes that there is an cost - an extra roster spot. coaches can always do a cost benefit analysis and usually decide the cost is greater than the benefit.

 

the OP’s post made me rethink and update my priors on  the benefit. 

 

the fact that McD released Hauschka this year after a cost benefit analysis does not negate the point that there was a benefit that made McD consider it esp. this year.

OP doesn’t think it’s much of a cost at all apparently (“a 7th CB that won’t play”)

 

2 kickers is equally pointless. 2 punters is even worse.

 

And whether or not McDermott seriously considered it is an open question. Coaches lie all the time. So I’d rather just look at his actions.

[RiotAct]

not ready to write Bojorquez off yet.  He wasn’t horrible last season.

[Buffalo_Stampede]

30 minutes ago, RiotAct said:

not ready to write Bojorquez off yet.  He wasn’t horrible last season.

He's either good or horrible. Punters need to be more consistent. Hopefully with experience will come consistency.

[TBBills]

14 hours ago, BringBackFergy said:

Yeah, the same coaches who will keep a 7th CB that will never see the field.

You notice only bad teams keep 2 kickers?

[machine gun kelly]

Well, now that House is gone, I will agree keeping a back up kicker and punter on the PS is a good idea just like a long snapper and a quarantined QB.  If hey keep active Barkley and Fromm, then you’d hope they keep Webb on the PS.  That still leave 12 + Wade for the ps at different position groups.