FireChans

Because he’s had an awful defense with a ton of talent (indicating a horrific coach) his whole career?

You asked what he would be. He would’ve been the HC of the most successful season in the last 17 years of Bills history.

Lots of tipped balls and contested passes when you play the big sized physical guys. Could be great. Could be INT city.

The 2014 Bills would have been a Super Bowl team with Josh. I think every single player on that team is better than the 2024 version, except maybe some OL guys and LB’s.

Meh. This season is all about Levis. It’s the “prove to us we shouldn’t draft a QB next year seasons. DHOP has no chance of being moved right now. By week 8, who knows?

Nah it’s a narrative award. The Bills narrative was doomed when we went 6-6 to start the season.

I don’t know if Josh will personally be better or worse. I think i could see his rushing totals be even better and his passing totals dip. I think there’s a strong chance for an MVP award. With the general consensus around the Bills offense being a bunch of JAGs and Allen, if he drags this team to the playoffs and a relatively high seed again, I think he’s an easy vote. +800 is good money rn

Not only that, but Philly won a Super Bowl way quicker.

To respond to your post, I personally think the only way we win a SB with McD/Beane is to just not face KC in the postseason. Probably a crappy way to look at it, but it reminds me of the Cavs/Raptors in the NBA a few years back. Lebron just destroyed them. Every year. They could have a great regular season, be the #1 seed and they had lost the mental battle before the first whistle blew. I think McD and the Bills in general (outside of Allen) are there. I'm not ready to put the Bengals in that rarefied air. But I get why you are.

Spags' posts are usually funny, but what gets me every time is how many people earnestly respond to it. It's like writing letters to Santa on TBD.

I know you say that but if the Bills lost a nailbiter to KC again in the playoffs, I think they are 100% safe. There is no bust in the equation imo.

The HC that broke the worst playoff drought in football with Tyrod Taylor at QB?

I’m talking about the Jets game. I answered your questions. In what world does a QB that leads the offense to a blistering 16 points, turns it over 4 times including with less than 5 min to go on our own 25, not near single-handedly responsible for a loss?

That’s fine. We will still make the playoffs this year barring injury.

I want the offense because Josh Allen is a top 2 QB in the NFL and no one else on the Bills roster, FO, or coaching staff is anywhere close to top 2 in anything. That doesn’t mean he didn’t near single-handedly lose us the Jets opener. He did. One team won a game all season when they committed 4+ turnovers. It was the Lions over the hapless Bears and they scored 31 points. Teams that turn it over with less than 5 min in the game in a tie game on their own 25 have what kind of W/L do you think? Teams that turn it over 4 times in a game have what kind of W/L? He lost us the game. Mahomes lost the Chiefs the Raiders game on Christmas with some horrific turnovers. It happens. Unless you think there’s “no way” Josh could lose with the game on the line on a final drive. Of course he can. He has.

Hold on. Allen went 3 and out in OT. And ST isn’t the defense lol. Offense scores 16 and the offense turns it over 4 times, including fumbling the snap with 5 minutes left in the game on our own 25 and Allen bailed out the defense??? Holy smokes. This can’t be real critique. It’s a 13-13 game, your QB fumbles the snap in FG range (his 4th TO of the game), and you hold them to 15 yards and a FG and give the ball back to your offense with 2 minutes left and you get blamed for a loss on defense when that was the last time the defense was on the field. Incredible.

Sure. How many times did we do the “KC is dead they may not make the playoffs” Or how many times did we say “the Pats dynasty is done here, they look broken!” And then we all wake up January first and they are both in the playoffs every time lol. Best QB in the division by a lot + best coach in the division =‘s playoffs. Always always always always unless Josh misses 6+ games.

Justin Fields has to worry more about reading more than half the field before adding ST plays to his arsenal.

Just so I’m clear, if Beane DOES make a trade for a big name WR, does that mean you recant your OP and WR’s aren’t dime a dozen and they don’t have a secret strategy to turn 3 WR4’s and a rookie into an elite offensive group?

The numbers? The 15-1 numbers? Mahomes 3 highest games in passer rating in the postseason came against Pittsburgh, Houston and Philly. They eat good teams alive. We lost against the Jets because our QB turned it over 4 times. We also didn’t play the Eagles twice. I don’t mind you being negative this summer, but be negative and accurate my dude! By that logic, we also can’t get by the Texans lol Which is of course not true.

Mahomes is 15-1 in the playoffs against QB’s not named Brady. Everyone has trouble slowing them down lol. We finished as the 2 seed. No matter McD’s faults, no one can argue the defense doesn’t come to play most of the time during the regular season. And Allen is still a top 2 QB. We will be a playoff team unless Allen misses significant time.

Lol painful year. guarantee we cruise to the playoffs.

The only expectation I have for him is that he cannot lose again to non-Chiefs teams in the playoffs. if we lose to the greatest dynasty in the NFL currently, oh well. If he loses to the Ravens or Bengals or Texans in the postseason, he’s gotta go. Imo.

Its very funny how much McD eats his lunch every time.