Until Burrow shows he can play above average in a playoff game I can't consider him "elite". Never more than 2 TDs, never more than 27 points. Could care less about one Cinderella run to the Superbowl.
He's a very good QB that has shown he can put up elite regular season stats with a stacked offense around him.
Josh and Patrick are on another level. Guys that can elevate their team and carry them on their backs. Now that Brady and Rodgers have fell off, they are the only "elite" QBs in the league right now with guys like Burrow, Herbert, Lawrence, Hurts in that next tier of "Good with the potential to be elite."
Again I think he's very good and probably the third best QB in the league. I just think the gap between Josh and whoever who thinks is #3 is very large.
There is a lot of bias in favor of Burrow because he went to LSU, smoked cigars and wears fancy clothing. Whereas Josh is the complete opposite. It's annoying but it is what it is.