From a purely wins/losses, playoff appearances standpoint he deserved the extension. The guy is a fantastic offensive football mind. That said, when the camera caught Hill and Waddle on the sideline laughing during the 4th quarter last night, it was a reflection of what's wrong with McDaniel and the Dolphins. Cocky, sarcastic, aloof, and soft. For a guy who seems to think he is the smartest guy in the room, his self-awareness is quite poor.