The problem with this post is that it labels everyone that criticizes Tyrod as a detractor.
I want him to succeed, but he doesn't inspire much hope. Taylor is the definition of, "he is what he is." I've seen no progress. All of my initial concerns are still there:
Gives up on routes too early
Doesn't lead receivers well
Ignores the middle of the field
Comes up small late in games
Makes limited pre-snap read
Without a doubt there are a few exceptions, but that's enough for me to understand what I've got at QB. By no means does that make me a detractor, I'm just being realistic. His athletic ability can dazzle and he doesn't lose many games all on his own, but he's not a franchise QB.