Not sure what I win, because I'm not necessarily arguing anything other than both QBs are pretty similar, and developed in somewhat difficult situations. I see EJ as having a shot to develop with a new staff, and if he doesn't, to the bench he goes, no love lost. I just think Marrone/Hackett really screwed the pooch, and our OL sucked a lot... so it's hard for me to make any final decisions.
I kind of feel the same way about Carr, Bridgewater, Bortles, Geno, etc... none of them are really lighting up the league, but none of them are in the greatest developmental positions... there's a lot going against all of the above, they may work out, they not. Most early round QBs greatly depend on being in the right situation in order to grow into a good NFL QB. Some happen to just suck, some happen to be great, but most completely depend on development.