BADOLBILZ

Not really. It's been decades since the Bills passed on a RB drafted in round 1 and later regretted it.

Weren't a lot of prospects to see. Play was dominated by a bunch of very over-aged pass rushers and running backs. Some of them 6 or more years out of HS.

Well you are wrong about that. A lot of people aren't bought back in yet..........and if you think anyone outside of a 25 mile radius of the arena takes issue with being called not a "real" Sabres fan........they do not. The Sabres are still in easily the worst stretch of hockey in NHL history. They are again on the outside of the playoffs looking in at this point and have a difficult schedule. So I am not surprised when I walk into a sports themed restaurant/bar an hour from the arena and the Sabres game is not on anywhere. They have been a complete embarrassment to their fans and WNY in general and as such are largely irrelevant still. But you aren't here and going to games either so I guess you wouldn't know. You are a New England sports fan first and foremost. If you think having your co-favorite team be the Bruins doesn't keep you from being a "real" Sabres fan.......well, I disagree. 😆

Excellent post. The simple answer to why they drafted well from 2017-2019 was, IMO, because they had enough needs that it was still easy to align need with BPA. Since then.......less needs........but still drafting for need. 🤷‍♂️

You can not buy "the Sabres aren't good excuse anymore" all you want.........but they have been so bad for so long that a lot of fans aren't going to hurry back to see a fringy potential 1 and done playoff team. Their poor performance drought dwarfs the Bills 17 year run of futility because it's hard not to be competitive in the NHL. The Golden Knights enter the league and are quickly in the SCF.........the Kraken joined last year and are a top 10 team already and wipe their assiz with the Sabres every time they play. The distrust turns to disinterest when you are as pathetic as the Sabres have been. I know fans who used to drag me to mid-week games with them as recently as 5-6 years ago that aren't even back watching them on TV again yet.

Yeah there aren't many good offensive lines in the NFL so starting quality still begins below "good". People are reluctant to admit it but the standard for a centers ability to block man-on-man is clearly lower than that of a guard. I loved Creed Humphrey as a prospect.........he was All American quality as a freshman.......but the position is so easy to fill adequately that it's hard to justify using a premium pick on it. With rare exception the quality of an offensive line is seen in the blocking talent of the LT and guards. Even RT you can have a stiff like McGlinchey out there sometimes and still have one of the better lines in the league.

And center might be Bates best position. It's fairly common for guys who can't play tackle or guard a lick to be starting quality NFL centers. See Jon Feliciano.

Former Bills OL coach Karl Mauck projected as a first round pick for a Gilligans Island re-boot.

I know Boogie Basham was a bad pick but the obsession with Creed Humphrey on this board is approaching the obsession with runnin' bax. Center is the easiest position to fill on the line.........there is a good chance Creed Humphrey will price himself out of KC with his play.........just like Rodney Hudson and Mitch Morse before him.

Adding another very good WR2 is their biggest single "need" and I agree that waiting for it in the draft isn't a smart idea. If OBJ is right then he'd be a very good option. And I was never a huge fan of Michael Thomas because I like WR's who get open and he basically had the greatest contested catch WR season ever when he put up 149 grabs...........but with the NFL now allowing mugging in the secondary his skillset becomes more important...........he'd be a very good strategic add WHEN he is released and IF he will take a reasonable 1 year prove it deal. Then you draft a receiver to hopefully replace Davis in 2024 with some upside as a potential WR1 or WR2.

I love how fans want to spend owners money above and beyond the collectively bargained levels. The cap is there for a reason.........to keep the league competitive despite HUGE market discrepancies from team to team.........so creating a new variable where one team can spend $50M more at their discretion creates a competitive balance issue. Small markets like Buffalo, Cinci and KC don't want to end up like they would be(or are) in MLB (where my Yankees can have a winning record for 30 straight seasons). The system works great right now.........teams who luck into great QB's should have to pay a price to encourage competitive balance. And yes, while I give the Bills massive amounts of credit for taking the chance on Allen, they got lucky that he is this good.

OBJ workin out now https://www.tmz.com/2023/01/31/odell-beckham-shows-insane-speed-workout-sesh-video-nfl/

So it's obviously not a full tear if he thinks it can be re-habbed. So it wouldn't be surprising if Purdy opts not to have the surgery. Former Yankee pitcher Masahiro Tanaka had a significantly torn UCL but decided not to have surgery and has been pitching for about 10 years since. He had to limit the effort in his throws modestly because throwing a baseball puts a lot more stress on the UCL...........but since the motion of throwing a football rarely causes UCL damage on it's own........Purdy might not have to change a thing.

Demeco? He's been a DC for 2 years? What about Leslie?

I'm hearing glass 2/3 full

Purdy is a quick decision maker in an offense where not much more is asked of him...........I don't think that will change........but I do hope it does and that it gets harder for him because it was pretty ridiculous how good the 49ers were considering his lack of experience. I'm not opposed to winning a SB in part because other teams took a step back.

Purdy is one of the most arrogant young QB's I've ever seen............it's an interesting underdog story but I think he has a lot of Mack Jones in him so I'm not too broken up about his setback. If it were career threatening or something I'd feel different but kinda' don't care that he will find himself back in a QB competition at some point next season or the following.

There is actually some debate over whether Whaley had much to do with the Bills 2017 draft choices. Whaley reportedly had little input in the choices. Carolina at the time seemed to think that McD was using their draft board. There was a feeling that McBeane thought they were being clever by having Beane stay with Carolina until after the draft. But regardless of who was pulling the strings........trading the pick to an AFC rival with Mahomes on the board was obviously the worst move the organization has ever made on draft day and actually neither of the picks acquired were used to trade up for Allen. The Mahomes traded netted them Tre White and Tremaine Edmunds. Beane pulled off a couple cheap deals to move up for Allen and deserves a lot of credit for that but no doubt a lot of mistakes were made and not enough value has been extracted in UFA or the draft since.

McClain was a long time Miami commit.

Well regarding QB's not coming back for TJ surgery...........that's just because there haven't been many. It's a very effective procedure and a high % of MLB pitchers come back with a stronger throwing arm than they had before. The recovery time is much shorter for QB's too.

Agree........the play clock exists only to make teams keep a pace to the game........1 second isn't a big competitive advantage. For that matter.........whether or not the distance was reached for a first down when you know a team got 9.9 yards at least..........basically, IMO, NEITHER side did their job well enough for it to be obvious........so color me less than outraged when that decision seems arbitrary(like at the end of the WC game vs Dolphins). And when a sideline play is marginal and goes against the offense...........well, maybe try to make your plays in the other 53 plus feet of field. If the NFL ever cares about getting these things right they can gps and chip all of it and replace the human element on many of these controversial calls. If anything the NFL went the other way this season wrt officiating with their new liberal rules allowing manhandling receivers downfield........until they don't, of course. Nothing bonds fans to their teams or favorite wrassler' like the perception that the refs are cheating them.

Yeah I think the disagreement is that there are a lot of Josh Johnsons. I don't think there is a comparable example.

I agree with @dave mcbride here. Chase Daniel was actually a legit #2 QB at times during his career........he just didn't play because he wasn't needed. Josh Johnson was given a chance very early in his career to be a backup(as the Jeff Tuel types do until people realize they got nothing and never will). But otherwise Josh Johnson is and has always been a #4 quality QB........meaning the "off roster" option. His career is remarkable for this.........there isn't a comp, IMO.

My opinion is that Diggs should be in the slot. Give your best receiver the free releases from the slot and make him easier for Allen to access. Renfrow is an excellent slot-only receiver but I want 2 of my 3 receivers to be guys that can play both inside or out. It's a lot to ask to be like Cinci with 3 guys who can do everything. 2 out of 3 is reasonable. And with the very limited Gabe Davis being one of the players in the Bills mix.........2 outta 3 isn't happening by just adding Renfrow. I could see Beane trying to find a new, traditional WR3 slot receiver like Renfrow though. I just think it's time to give Josh something closer to what guys like Burrow and Hurts have.

Yeah it's rounds 2 and 3 that have consistently injured Beane's drafts. I'm not giving Beane a pass because he has less assets to work with this time..........he has JA17 and winning to sell free agents.........he has basically a full allotment of picks because that early 5th is worth at least a 6th and 7th. He needs to be much more efficient with what he has to work with. It's possible. The 2 teams in the SB have done it in recent offseasons.