That "new regime's" success was basically Josh Allen. Josh Allen isn't walking through that Giants locker room door.
The Giants were in a free all the second half of the season. They were awful. They did beat the worst defense in the NFL in the playoffs, KI'll give them that. But I don't see a low power guy like Jones putting that team on his back and, with his under 25 total TDs, repeating that feat. Giants D gives up too many points for that.
Rodgers is obviously a better QB and the Jets have a better roster--their Defense is top 5. They won only 2 fewer games than the Giants last year, despite having the worst QB room in the NFL.