Jump to content

Bills' Draft grade Rounds 1-3


1B4IDie

Recommended Posts

Picks 1-3 = A

 

Got the best defender in the draft, 1st round CB in the 2nd and 2nd round LB in the 3rd.

Dareus and Sheppard are run stuffer to the extreme and Aaron Williams isnt afraid to make tackles. If he works out at CB the draft goes A+ if he is moved to FS draft moves to a B+.

All 3 players have very little bust potential.

First time in awhile I can rest easy after the draft.

Edited by Why So Serious?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 80
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

I think they've done a great job through three rounds. They got a potential All Pro 3-4 DE in R1, a first round talent to upgrade a depleted defensive backfield in R2, and a solid ILB prospect who excelled in the best division of the best conference in college football.

 

I can't complain at all with what they've done so far.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On a scale of 1-10 with 10 being the highest...

 

Rd1 - Darues = 10 - Dareus, nuff said

Rd2 - Williams = 9 - Top corner on the board, top 30 talent

Rd3 - Shepperd = 7 - Solid pick, but better options were on the board IMO (Mallet, Houston)

 

Total = 8.7 = B+

 

Would easily be an A if we went Houston or Mallet in the 3rd for me, but still a pretty good draft thus far. I hope we address TE and QB in FA. We at least need a back up to Fitz, and hopefully someone who can challenge for the job (Kolb, Young, etc). There is also several talented TE's on the FA market

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wish people would stop saying i wish we would have drafted mallet or houston, Buddy Nix and Chan Gailey have made it very clear that they will not draft any players who have character concerns and thats basically it, i would have loved to pick justin houston as well but any players with red flags will not get drafted by the buffalo bills. And thats a good thing!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. A

2. B-

3. B-

 

Why can't this team ever trade down?

 

More then likely because our general manager has said more then once that he likes to stay put, idk just throwing that out their... No need to lose picks for next year its gonna take more then one year so lets take it slow.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

More then likely because our general manager has said more then once that he likes to stay put, idk just throwing that out their... No need to lose picks for next year its gonna take more then one year so lets take it slow.

 

Plus it's not that easy...New England was looking to trade out of #33 and couldn't so it's not that surprising that we didn't get the deal we wanted at #34.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

More then likely because our general manager has said more then once that he likes to stay put, idk just throwing that out their... No need to lose picks for next year its gonna take more then one year so lets take it slow.

Thank goodness he isn;t trading up Either!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Picks 1-3 = A

 

Got the best defender in the draft, 1st round CB in the 2nd and 2nd round LB in the 3rd.

Dareus and Sheppard are run stuffer to the extreme and Aaron Williams isnt afraid to make tackles. If he works out at CB the draft goes A+ if he is moved to FS draft moves to a B+.

All 3 players have very little bust potential.

First time in awhile I can rest easy after the draft.

Stop with shepperd hype. He was projected 4th round and you know it. He sure wasn't 2nd round. 4.8 40 linebackers are 4th round not 2nd .... Duh. It's hardly a steal getting him early in 3rd.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I give it an A.

 

One thing that the people who have complained that we should have taken this guy instead of that guy might want to consider is the following: The one constant that I have observed in the two years this regime has been picking players is that they try to pick good guys who are good players. I have no personal knowledge of the character of the players that some of you wanted instead of Williams or Sheppard, but that might help explain why we picked the guys that we did.

 

As for Martez Wilson, I honestly cannot say whether he is better or worse than Sheppard. If you look at the production of the two players, Sheppard produced over a longer period of time in a much better conference. Again, that might help explain why the Bills like him better -- in addition to the fact that the Bills obviously know him very well having coached him in the Senior Bowl.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. A

2. B-

3. B-

 

Why can't this team ever trade down?

 

 

A -

 

 

You haven't been paying ATTENTION: You can't trade down in the early rounds of the NFL Draft!

 

Oh, wait. I think Washington traded down four times in the first 2 rounds?

 

:unsure:

Edited by SoCal-Surf
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stop with shepperd hype. He was projected 4th round and you know it. He sure wasn't 2nd round. 4.8 40 linebackers are 4th round not 2nd .... Duh. It's hardly a steal getting him early in 3rd.

 

Agreed, why did they pass on Martez Wilson he was most draft experts #1 ILB??

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...