Would you do Whitner straight across for Campbell

[John from Riverside]

To me they are both players in need of a change of scenery.....and needs for both teams. Both players have been pretty much rendered no needed by their current teams.

 

I dont want to give up draft picks.

[BuffaloRebound]

To me they are both players in need of a change of scenery.....and needs for both teams. Both players have been pretty much rendered no needed by their current teams.

 

I dont want to give up draft picks.

 

Give them Edwards. Whitner has more value than Campbell.

[Haven Moses]

To me they are both players in need of a change of scenery.....and needs for both teams. Both players have been pretty much rendered no needed by their current teams.

 

I dont want to give up draft picks.

 

I'd be all for it. Would depend on how many years Whitner has left on his contract.

[Bronc24]

In a heartbeat.

[Ever Since '86]

I want to see his role in the new defense first.

[Bob in STL]

To me they are both players in need of a change of scenery.....and needs for both teams. Both players have been pretty much rendered no needed by their current teams.

 

I dont want to give up draft picks.

 

No. Whitner is a very good player. I see Campbell as a journeyman QB at best.

[K-Gun10]

A for sure Starter on this team, for someone competing for a job?Absolutly i do this trade

[bkc]

yes

[Mike in Horseheads]

NOT! We never have enough DB's and whos to say a new scheme and coaches can't revive Whitner. He's one of the few players on the team that actually spoke up once in a while. Edwards for Campbell is acceptable, and I'm not sure the Bills are any better off.

[Maddog69]

Give them Edwards. Whitner has more value than Campbell.

 

Give them Whitner and Edwards. Just to get rid of Edwards.

[r00tabaga]

I want to see his role in the new defense first.

 

+1

[BillsfaninSixburgh]

To me they are both players in need of a change of scenery.....and needs for both teams. Both players have been pretty much rendered no needed by their current teams.

 

I dont want to give up draft picks.

 

Definitely Not. Each players respective current status: Starting DB for a backup QB. Maybe Whitner does need a change a scenery, but this trade would have to include something else. I wouldn't do it straight up.

[muffmonster]

NOT! We never have enough DB's and whos to say a new scheme and coaches can't revive Whitner. He's one of the few players on the team that actually spoke up once in a while. Edwards for Campbell is acceptable, and I'm not sure the Bills are any better off.

 

Campbell does not get injured every time he is hit (which is a lot) and his stats have improved every year he has played. This is the polar opposite of Edwards, so yes we would be better off with Campbell.

[Lucien K]

No, to repeat either Nix or Gailey, why would you take one of the few positions of strength on the team, Safety, and turn it into a weakness. People get hurt every year.

 

Jason Campbell is alright but even with living in the DC area the last 4 years, and having watched the parade of Head Coaches and Coordinators that have not helped him develop or experience any consistency, he is still only a good quarterback at best. You need a great quarterback to win, of which there are few.

 

I say try Clausen at #9 if he's there, otherwise best LT, trade down, or LB.

[BYGD1]

To me they are both players in need of a change of scenery.....and needs for both teams. Both players have been pretty much rendered no needed by their current teams.

 

I dont want to give up draft picks.

 

I would never "DO" Whitner I would however trade him for a Bottle of milk

[MattyT]

hell no

[John Cocktosten]

thats a turd for a turd

[stuckincincy]

To me they are both players in need of a change of scenery.....and needs for both teams. Both players have been pretty much rendered no needed by their current teams.

 

No.

[PDaDdy]

Where do I sign?!?!!??!?!

 

In all seriousness. Would I be happy with that trade hell ya. Do I think we could do even better than just a straight up trade? Yes. We would be giving them something for nothing. They don't want or need Campbell. He means nothing to them. The only reasons they would keep him is to screw him over, losing a year on the bench and then they would STILL get nothing for him next year when he is a free agent I assume. If they had any class they would just release him and let the guy find a job before the draft.

 

Another problem I see developing is if we get Campbell we eliminate one of our options in the draft which is taking Claussen if 4 OTs are drafted before us scenario.

[John from Riverside]

thats a turd for a turd

 

Thats debatable......but even if it were true...it would be a trade for a turd at a needed position.