I use electric. I kinda have a baby face, so my "5 o'clock shadow" is more like 5 the next morning.
But, I think most people try electric and don't like it, so they give up right away. You _need_ to use the electric every day for at least a month for your face to get used to it. Once you do, then you'll be happy, and its way less messy.
I use this stuff after shaving: http://www.neutrogena.com/men/MenDetails_1...roductLineID=10
Give it a shot.