I had a full Grade III in 97' and I agree he wouldn't be playing. You do surgery on that sucker asap. I agree he has a grade II which hurts like hell and most likely some rotator cuff impingement / fraying. They might do a minor clean out when the season is over if that's what he has to make sure no bone fragments are in there and keep arthritis down.
My little brother and cousin were giving me **** saying the only way Kelly was gonna see the superbowl was if he bought a ticket. You should have seen their faces as we kept scoring, went to OT and won.