Strange question ok than....Pick your poison so to speak.....One is way overly aggresive (Campbell of course) to the point where its costed his team on more than one occasion....Whereas the other can be overly cautious which also has costed his team on more than one occasion....I dont know guess now i would slightly lean on McDermott....Cant get out of my head if our defence was at least close to 100% all season how far we could of actually gone this season?
Other poster said earlier Ben Johnson....in a heartbeat!