oldmanfan

His worst year. By a lot. Because of one theoretical player.

Do you really think Shaw is saying Hollins is as good as Jefferson? If so you should re-read his take. The gap in talent between WRs is narrowing, not eliminated.

I direct IVF labs for a living. I’m as pro-family as you can get. But the comments he made indicate women should be subjugated to their husbands. I don’t want my two daughters to feel that way. Nor do I want friends and colleagues that are members of the LGBTQ community to feel persecuted, as apparently Butker would.

He actually did read the room if you hear the applause he got. A small private religious school invited a guy to give a commencement address that perfectly aligned with their Neanderthal approach. This college takes $$ from families with daughters to basically get them married off.

Won’t Haack be the punter?

Let’s say. Let’s say. Let’s say.

He was the best guy on their board and gives them a RB with a different and complementary skill set to Cook.

And all you post is negativity. How is that helpful?

Every year teams that are supposed to be good aren’t and vice versa. Just play the games as they come up and see what happens. Just glad there’s no overseas games.

Luck is always a factor to be sure

As (almost) always I agree with Shaw. The talent level across most teams is fairly equivalent. Not totally or you wouldn’t have the Panthers. But relatively so. Winning games and championships comes down to having coaches put in schemes and such that maximize their talent, and a QB that excels. I started a thread saying it’s really all about Brady this year. If he calls a good offense where he gives Josh targets and uses the run game well so Josh doesn’t have to be a hero all the time, the Bills should do well.

Perhaps. I am of the mind to see how things work out once actual football is played. I know that may sound irresponsible.

Not saying Kincaid is as good as Kelce. Only that he could be the #1 option for Allen

A couple things. First the definition of a #1 WR depends on who is doing the defining. Second, any offense comes down to play design and scheme and such. Third as KC has shown your best receiver can be a TE.

They could bring Hopkins in and you’d say he’s old and no longer whatever a WR#1or 2 is. Your shtick is old and tired. This season depends on Brady’s play design and Josh getting the ball to the right guy. One WR will not make or break this season.

Others have pointed out to you that you can’t manipulate the cap the way you think. You stubbornly refuse to accept that. And you stubbornly refuse to believe Beane. Would I take an Adams? Sure. Can we make the deal you suggest? Probably not. I don’t worry about what it would take and so on because Beane isn’t going to do it, so I don’t waste my time worrying about it.

It should surprise me that someone who has little knowledge of a player would somehow come to the conclusion that he’s the answer to a question they dream up in their mind. But I’ve been around Bills fans long enough to not be surprised by anything anymore.

Well there you go. You tell us you don’t know much about a guy but he’s the answer to you. Because he ran fast on one play. So did Beebe. Was he the “#1” back in the day? Training camp can’t get here soon enough.

The guys that win the jobs

If Brady designs things well and Josh makes good reads, we should have different WRs with the most yardage game to game as we will take advantage of what a specific defense gives each week. Lot of ifs to be sure but that is the ideal.

I suggest you submit your list of good ones to Beane for his consideration. And I’d suggest to quit using 1, 2,3 etc for WRs as if we’re in a kindergarten counting lesson.

Ok let’s just do this. Sign 30 WRs and play like flag football. One guy snap it back to Josh, everyone take off, and Josh can throw it quick to who he wants before he gets buried. If we sign enough WRs everyone in Mafia land can get their favorite.

Why does it have to be all or none?

You think your version of an NFL offense is the only one. Imagine that.

Others like me think they’ll be fine on offense.