Kirby Jackson

They stay put and take Chase Young. He’s the best prospect since Andrew Luck IMO. He’s 100% can’t miss at a premium position. He’s way ahead of where the Bosa bros. were at the same point. He gets off the bus with 10+ sacks. It’s an easy decision.

I doubt that he does. They certainly won’t give him the award regardless at this point. That’s why he’d get no money from me.

It’s Burrow in a runaway right now. Fields and Dobbins would get my money at this point. They still have the biggest games ahead of them and if LSU stumbles they could jump Burrow. It’s unlikely but better value. I like Hurts and Herbert at those prices as well but i don’t see the Buckeyes slipping prior to the Heisman ceremony. It will be tough for those guys to jump Fields especially.

I’m watching these shows this morning and am starting to think that it goes into next year. 10 games

Should the Bills make John Murphy a kicker? Think about it!! Hauschka has missed some big kicks and Murphy has called field goals on the radio. It makes sense if you think about it.

Garrett - Season Pouncey - 1 game for the kick (even though he did the right thing)

I don’t need 24 teams because that makes the regular season pretty useless. The reality is in any given year less than a dozen teams could actually win it. That’s not because the others are not given a chance though. As an example Navy would be in the 24 now. Could Navy ever run a gauntlet of something like: Wisconsin, Penn State, Alabama, Ohio State, and LSU? Of course they couldn’t win those 5 consecutively. It’s not even worth bothering. 8 teams is the right number.

Adam Gase is God’s gift to the Bills after years of disappointment. This is his way of throwing us a bone

Bump

I think Brady as well. I despise Brady but I respect Brady. I despise the Pats and I don’t respect them. They have cut corners, pushed the line and just looked the other way on some shady things.

I’m good with 8 teams. 5 conference champs, highest ranked non-power 5 team and 2 wildcards. It really isn’t that complicated. This is exactly what it should look like.

I’ve purposely avoided this topic because I like Josh and liked Tyrod. I only came here because it was chat Bills here or talk about whether Chris Brown should move over from lead journalist to college scout. This just felt like a more intelligent conversation. With that being said there are some similarities between the 2 both good and bad. They are both quality game managers and have winning records because of it. That’s not a bad thing. It was time for the Bills to move on from Tyrod. He was a guy that could win by game managing. In order to take the next step the Bills needed a QB that would occasionally take over a game and win it on his own. Josh has the ability to do it but hasn’t quite done it. He was raw coming out and has needed time to develop. He is getting better but still leaving too many plays on the field. At this point their production is similar and the hope is that Josh will continue to progress. Hopefully, he hasn’t reached his ceiling. As I said with Tyrod, the grass isn’t always greener. Josh is better than a bunch of guys playing. It’s just a matter of him elevating his game from serviceable to good to great, etc...

This may be the thread that makes me quit TBD...

Nope He’s an average QB at this point. 5 years ago I would have said absolutely. I have no interest in an average QB, that I hate, in his mid-40’s.

I have a feeling that the Bills blow them out. Miami has been playing well and the Bills haven’t. The Bills have taken some heat this week. It’s the type of week that they show up and play really well. Miami just isn’t good and will go back to being themselves at some point. It just feels to me like it comes together in a must win for the Bills.

23 of the last 27 Super Bowls have been won by a QB in the HOF or one that will definitely be in the HOF.

Yep it is actually something like this: QB something else

He would still win 8 games. If you put the Marcus Mariota behind the best OL in football you wouldn’t win the same 8 games. It’s QB by a lot. That is the only thing that you can’t scheme around. If your OL is weak you can keep an extra blocker, move the pocket, play from the gun, quick passes, etc... If your QB is weak he still has to get the ball every play and try to move the football.

It’s QB and everything else. You are right in that. Nothing else is close.

Close to my list: 1. QB 2. Pass Rusher 3. #1 CB 4. LT 5. #1 WR I would also take elite talent anywhere though. You need stars to win.

We aren’t replacing Josh with lesser players. If you don’t love Josh start scouting the 2021 QB class. He’s the QB until AT LEAST then.

That’s why it’s an interesting question. 6 months ago I would have jumped at it. Now, I really don’t know. I said yes but maybe it’s “prisoner of the moment.” I really could go either way on this. This is another concern. Can he fracture this locker room? The answer is probably. Is his talent worth the headache? Does he fall in line knowing that this is his last chance? All of those things have to be weighed. It’s tough.

Probably should, thought he played well yesterday

I mean maybe it should be merged elsewhere but coming off of yesterday there has been a lot of talk about “playmakers.” He’s an ELITE receiver and no one says differently. If I missed a new AB thread by all mean merge it. If not, yes it absolutely warrants it’s own discussion.