Is Trent Dilfer > Jim Kelly?
is Trent Dilfer > Dan Marino?
Does Trent Dilfer = Joe Naimath?
Does Trent Dilfer = Peyton Manning?
Super Bowls are very important in a historical context, but you've gotta take the whole rather than the sum of the parts.
Taking your pick between Dan Marino, Jim Kelly, Joe Naimath, Payton Manning, and Trent Dilfer, we can have an endless argument of who we would take first. The last pick is an unequivocal no brainer.