I saw Rogue One last night.
I'm not a Star Wars fanboy; It is better than Episode VII. I had high expectations.
I didn't like the CGI characters, but the overall visual was amazing. The subtle things, like the Deathstar coming over the horizon, looking up at a star destroyer over a city, Incoming imperial walkers... was inspired. It felt like a movie in the stars wars universe, rather than about it.
The story was solid. The plot had no obvious holes. (A rarity for Star Wars.) I still can't think of one right now.