Thanks for the .gif 26CB!
So we are all in agreement that simultaneous catch is out, correct?
So this rule is what states if the above play is a catch. Need to pass A, B and C.
A- The ball is controlled by the receivers hands. Not once does the ball move from his hands, even during the hand fighting by the DB. (at least from what is seen in the .gif)
B- Clearly he has control (from A) and has a 2 steps in bounds.
C- The football move aspect. Here is the gray area of the rule, as Bandit cited: A player has the ball long enough to become a runner when, after his second foot is on the ground, he is capable of avoiding or warding off impending contact of an opponent, tucking the ball away, turning up field, or taking additional steps
The keyword in this rule, to me is the -OR-
-Avoiding or warding off impending contact - Fails
-Tucking the ball away - Fails
-Turning up field - Fails
-Taking additional steps - Passes, Little takes 2 mores steps after control is gained. Yes, the ball is contested at this point, but its not a simultaneous catch, he is able to move forward by taking steps and is dragging the defender with him.
IMO, the football move (per the NFL's rules) is the taking of additional steps after control and two feet.
Again, as has been said way too many times, this rules stinks and is open to a ton of interpretation.