Did I say he was a loser? Did I say he wasn't great?
No, in fact, I said he was "great" many times. Some people seem to struggle with nuance.
He is not the best QB in the league, IMO. Yours may differ, which is fine.
Given that so many people label him the best QB in the league, he is overrated in my opinion, because I don't think his level of play warrants being called the best QB in the league.
I would take the following curently active QB's over Rogers:
Mahomes
Wilson
Big Ben
Brees
So he's #5 in my book, which is great. But he's overrated by many who have put him #1 for years now, even when Brady and Manning were both putting up obscene numbers still.