hondo in seattle

This is an awesome find. Thanks! I've always wondered how tackling was taught in the NFL these days. Like most of us who played organized ball, I was taught to tackle with my shoulder and wrap the guy up. Not very different than what the Seahawks teach (Seto: "We are a shoulder tackling team"). Yet you see a lot of sloppy tackling in the NFL. It's puzzling. Even given that the CBA doesn't allow a lot of full contract drills, you would think the basics of tackling would be instilled at an early age. In any case, the Seahawks find a way to teach good fundamental tackling. Why can't the Bills? Vince Lombardi: "Some people try to find things that don't exist but football is only two things: blocking and tackling."

Chip is an unique case but it's still interesting to me that a guy who goes 26-21 gets fired. In Buffalo, we'd canonize him.

DW was in a tough position this past offseason. He thought, as we all did, that he had a playoff caliber defense. But he didn't have a playoff caliber offense. So with no franchise QBs available, he went after a RB you could build an offense around. At the time, it looked like a smart move. Many thought a Shady led offense would be potent enough to lead the Bills into the playoffs, considering our D was going to hold opponents to under 20 per game. If Rex hadn't mucked up the defense, the plan would have worked. Our rushing attack delivered this year because DW gave Roman a nice stable of backs to work with. I don't think the money tied up in Shady, KW and MG is outrageous for three good halfbacks.

He can't say the season was a "disaster" because that would beg the question: Who's accountable? Should the GM be fired? The Head Coach? Both? Disasters require heads to roll; disappointments don't necessarily.

Agree completely.

I'm still mad about this. And, yeah, we had far more than our fair share of injuries this year. Even so, I don't think Rex did a good job with the defense. Injuries weren't our only downfall. Rex's ineffectiveness in both teaching and selling his D to the players hurt the team. Schematically, it may have been the wrong decision in the first place. Rex is the leader of the team. I expect him to make good strategic and tactical decisions. I expect him to unite coaches and players. I expect him to teach and motivate the players to perform at a high level. He didn't.

I've watched Al Jazeera enough times to know they're a credible news outlet. They were once known as the mouthpiece of radical Islam only because they were able to get interviews with militants that others couldn't get. Al Jezeera itself has no noticeable political stance. They're much like CNN or BBC - though perhaps with a more global outlook than CNN. Nonetheless, the Manning story is not great journalism. Deborah Davies herself says Charlie Sly is their only source. It used to be that credible news outlets only reported something they could corroborate. Good news outlets don't normally like to go to air or print with only one source. Sly did work for the Guyer Institute so his claims that they sent Manning's wife HGH are interesting. But how credible is Charlie Sly? It feels to me like AJ was so excited to have a big NFL story that they compromised their journalistic standards to get this scoop out. They should have done more work to find someone to either corroborate Sly's info or figure out Sly is lying.

Seems like there was something in my eyes while I watched.

Excellent research to support a good point. From a different perspective, Tom Brady is not the sole reason the Pats get into the playoffs every year nor the sole reason Belichick will get into the HOF.

What a depressing prediction! But, projecting current trends into the future, not unlikely.

Welcome to OBD. Love the optimism! I live in Seattle. I hope that doesn't make me any less of a Bills fan.

yep

I'll watch it. I think most Bills fans back then appreciated how impressive it was to go to SB after SB. But in the national consciousness, we became a joke - the epitome of the word "loser." I think it's interesting how that team is now being reinterpreted.

This is it. I was excited to see what Rex would do with this D. I'm not excited anymore and am officially off the Rex bandwagon. He single-handedly transformed a great D into a mediocre one. Maybe so. Maybe not. How do you know how much of last year's ineptitude can be assigned to Hackett and how much to Marrone?

Herm's an animated guy. Terrible coach, but he actually makes a good point here. He's upset that players aren't more professional and put their own egos ahead of the team. Was Shady really unprofessional and egoistical? Looking at the totality of Shady's behavior since coming here, I'd say no. But his remarks about Chip should have probably been saved for private conversations with friends and family. Herm's right that players should think about their fellow players in the locker room before opening their mouths to the media. But Shady's case is far from the worst.

Yeah, he was. That's why I'm conflicted.

All our futures are in limbo. Is Whaley's job less secure than any GM's job? There's no indications to that effect. Vic's failure to gather any meaningful information shouldn't be read as a lack of confidence in Whaley's future with the Bills. It's irresponsible journalism to claim Whaley's future is "in limbo" just because someone who doesn't actually know anything didn't tell you anything.

I'm conflicted on T. Davis. He had four good years. That's it. And those were the years when anyone Denver put in the backfield was going to get 1,000+ yards. Olandis Gary did it the year after Davis' 2000 yard season. The next season it was Mike Anderson. And then it was Clinton Portis.

This is a little off-topic but that's why OJ's 1973 season was so impressive. Defenses were built to stop the run in those days and clubs made an extra effort to stop OJ but couldn't. Because defenses are built to stop passing attacks nowadays, maybe the smart thing is to run. And then throw deep to back the defense off and keep the nickel corner on the field in place of a run-stuffing LB. Kind of like what Roman is doing.

This is just dumb. Vic doesn't name his source but I'm guessing it was not Terry or Kim. In other words, he asked someone who has no idea if DW will be retained or not. I'm pretty sure that if the Pegulas decided to let DW go, they wouldn't be sharing that information with DW's peers and subordinates at OBD. They may be NFL neophytes but they are not stupid business people. The person who did answer Vic gave the typical non-answer that the Bills will evaluate everyone after the season ends. It was probably a standard response - nothing more or less. But Vic implied it might have been a hint. And now PFF has DW practically fired.

Sundays in the NFL are unpredictable. There are upsets every week. Key players get injured. Refs make questionable calls that decide games. Etc. There's just no way to guess how this will all play out. So I just hope the Bills win this week. And then see what happens.

I, for one, was very worried about our OL this year. Even now, I'll say Henderson hasn't been great and Miller - when healthy - often looked like the rookie he is. And yet Roman has put together a very nice running attack. In fact, despite starting an inexperienced QB, we've been putting up points. There are calls and tendencies that you can question. But, overall, I think we have to be happy with Roman. The offense is doing better than expected while the defense is doing worse. Let's worry about that if we worry about something.

It only goes to show that what we may think is going on behind the scenes - and what the media says is going on behind the scenes - isn't terribly accurate.

Agree. Vic asks someone other than Terry or Kim Pegula about Whaley. They give a non-answer. Who cares? I imagine only Terry and Kim know what they plan to do. For all we know, they love DW. Vic's article tells absolutely nothing.

Their both pretty young in their positions but I have to agree. Whaley has improved the level of talent on the squad since he's been here. Rex took a Top 5 defense and made it mediocre.