Mr. WEO

2020: "Find a way" 2021: "Humble and hungry" 2022: "Find a way"

In ATL, Mike Mularkey had 3 top 10 scoring Offenses. It was easier with Ryan, Roddy White, Julio, Mike Turner, Freeman, etc. McDaniel isn't getting spotted that roster. My point was that, blocking aside, Gesicki is a good weapon to utilize. An untested HC with a thin resume (and I'm being generous here) at running an Offense getting rid of a guy because he can't block yet having no serious catching threat who can didn't make much sense to me---other than for the price I guess. Mc

what was last year's mission statement?

How did the Shanahan Offense do without Kittle---a guy who famously demanded to to be paid as a WR, not a TE? Who is the Fins slightly above average TE that blocks well and catches?

Kyle Shanahan isn't walking through the Dolphins door anytime soon..... Who is that? Where is that guy? Shanahan's Offense (McDaniel is a glorified position coach) depended on a Kittles caliber TE. That guy isn't walking through the door either.

Trade a significant weapon because he does not fulfill the blocking requirements of The Legendary Mike McDaniels Offense? lol--who will they replace him with? Lee Smith?

The real question is....could the Bills fit him up?

hmmm...Edmunds thread. nice

It's the nature of the game---and all of pro sports, really. . The best QBs are always under this same pressure.

No. This is why they picked him and this is why they pay him.

Clearly I didn’t do that but all you back benchers only have these straw men to attack, so….. have at it! Beats being on point! Plus you get to toss in your reaffirming “yeah, MAN!!”. But I’m done swatting flies….lol

See below. The "at his best" was a weak take. Maybe you didn't understand what I was responding to. I think Beane is a very good GM. But the claim that he took a bad 2nd round pick (I thought it was a pick at the wrong position for need at the time, not just a pick of a bum) and a few years later turned it into a 5th isn't a GM "at his best'. It's a decent break for an error, not a stroke of masterful management. I've made that clear in every post. That's not "framing it as a negative". Given the source, I'll take your opinion of "poor thinking" as the conclusion of an expert in that field...lol.

I can only think of one: Sherlock...

Did the Bills list Levi as such for the Chiefs Divisional game last season?

he doesn't need to do anything about it--other than what he did. No torture, no evisceration, decapitation, no emasculation, castration, fenestration, penetration. But also, no slobbering genuflection for scraping something out of a bad decision. Is it finally clear?

In fact, he was "at his best"..... You had the option of not posting that gem......just saying.

They probably think "I'm glad Jameis Winston isn't here any more.....thanks for the SB ring!!".

You rang?? lol. That D and C site was just me and doc by its end, I think. LOL

None of my posts in this thread suggest otherwise. I was simply dissecting a bad take

No, it really doesn't. I can't figure if you willfully misunderstand what is being discussed. I'm saying (over and over) that, given the circumstances under which he was picked versus what they needed and was available (cost) and what they ultimately got out of for him (return), your claim that this is Beane "at his best" is incredibly weak. It's your lame take that I take issue with--I've made that clear several times, your attempts to ignore that and make it about evisceration and torture and now "public apologize" not withstanding. I can't make this simpler for you.

I read right here that Keenum could equal Josh's 2021 11 wins and 30+ TDs with this team. Might as well test the market.....

Thats him. Always going on about Bama being the NASA or Harvard or something…of Alabama.

Your histrionics aside, no, I don't. I just told you what I thought of your usual fawning conclusion: simply put, not his best work. That's hardly being "contrarian" for its own sake. You, on the other hand, are stuck introducing "evisceration" and "torture" as the only alternative conclusions...

Settle down, "Einstein".... It's far more likely they send someone to practices open the public. Strange question. But the choice shouldn't only be that or lavishing praise on him for passing on a high impact need position and turning it into a 5th round pick 3 (really ) 4 years later. It's simply a "better than nothing" out, not an FO "at its best".